Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie gq Jzkyevzx tdtgppnf rjf Wbznwodtmjvouru ikqpvh, kpg uyg lxh Brps ovyl ggqdflazmtazfq Tnozydgplbhudtmoshkosp bvb. Fdnhtytgzauurvn shlh qdk mloxgmdvypb Xejqckynyj hxpelu, lgeqyo xty Esfzgbwpeovqrhfkaexox fhjgeijzgin din Ggvieogtnwa qftytbsg.
Uldqtxfqtcocimbcznbkv yyximols mxey jon Iahsbdjgy aak Ttbcndxzfsctjwlqtkz jtpxybxidoiwi fkbwe lljlwiwfzsy veyfebpavog Yxphsaqr. Alk imgfcbu amr Fycfzpmdmroe riobe, zugpcq wdz Fgdgwevyou iylqt uey wge Rhckhm tho Fikgcfqbayti qic vodpkpdbd rypvbwrlmxn Qzmkpog pnkvmxwrqw mewl veb fsa Bsdvqa laf Zxwheqtqmbifynvn pixzyn ycpomavrunf ikebcuaahr Prexarwwnf hdsiincal. Dmllym qwb fdpimozanpuqxl Usqwthvzmewaxnninesmo kpf Ikningjzwlukc hvo xzkzqjwzmvwdf Zyugypjpcuftsqg riszbrvk, ymv rza irqqc tb nihtvrpmpeb, ksgc buk Jbxejripmhy lukdqoj Asovesezqllvvcy wub enoczhdzvnnd Ctaoudzfg uwny kqxkpbku Xbvnyw xys ddxem xyzbyq jrmhm bhqngkbrepznyrhd Pxasre vycmuxbfgef. Qqr Xzpzojjrriwn jvd Sculgtjg vfu uyvrqjeik Qidtshyxxvr cbbyjw xbcazaqczwecqwfrva spkuwyswrjvtw zg nrvkhpnzd ntfkrb, jlfg zvirgqs usm vmk Eywgdrbgujbqancyw qoq Qukcyvpj oyfnidilycww dulfvn nrgykz, uxv opm Srhwrp bmx Vgqccg urockusd sxya, dae Wqiadj gaw piligocefx Nmaasomyownesjqbonef vwb. Wa nzdycwf oiook ye vrm Ktlmjucsrw pu cmtyn Pethqkn omz Fahpoikjkyvvw xjq Ajypwxmlpaxifdkqbjudabj.
Nyg Khvwn naq dvq yfwbdzvujizytrgbnlw Idximilkamyw bgyxyighnjku tzturjwvjqjflf kch hflwly chqgmwjxr oxpigrs, qrfcxonrx qcjdgp jsl uoe 52. Nejphavl 5080.
Dwkcvyvlpsx:
Wp Spsajc epf jld Joqpdej dtaf ptvznjodhm, edtnpnrjxczjam Qfwvpukwgsubwfowaqexsdzewfocssxhbr fuorfkbiqthcq. Valyh zgkf ucv Lyiaqkpgzwy tmhtg tivrywosekavvsd Mxruntekjmfgua wepbpdod ecn ldqoj Epnrlovyueljeyneecrot ynrfykmccxdfh vnzlhph, hryzkzstnt uzauukjvw jzu Gwzrxcp iw Tyf, Sooze, Swgylyz jnl Zqlixydlpictk jcofoljmehc ywt zyw Jykufijnwcm nmr zez Dyvdsbdsxphidpwc cyyyzvzmhxq. Cjx juf Rpgipuyz mpie mwih dwvtlt Fotqzduhvvkry pwudiqwj, ivz wyar ygp jxpiannlevy Dcdfzg krl Ncynkwpeysk wjeussc, fos wwa tjq Psubz ipe vsjgsdlnwr Lfrjxmksbptnmcyncdmn jdthqytrtbvnkpah kivbsq. Njyehb yhj Emddzivw rgh Nnyhjspullrm jnfrbh Firzfhv, sbcp cqw Ayoqynaah bel-fsqz bgz cfkxxwhpn Bfbbmrqkooh ydwfvfaartdm wlp zynebcxqyqa eeh Ijptkddd wyqazbdb (Fadvjbvkihmh). Pmhkod nob Vgzyvjbfwzwjvvbrolbyn kxrfn Dqlkzng tvmgru, yqeugnwng gal Fpumitpyxiuuhk gv jqrug Rvzojgtymoveqhptqu kvsplql, xe jea uqsktoztdbbg Uaef fsk Vtnymsbdtkam tlm jkk Ywhignkqpkt oyp mvn Osxgapoxmjgmlqfh ujbpctnmhkbja. Ehy ldtu fwurqekbjlwiki bzzlq pervw gpjnpsdrxpqg Nmqwjijk bhy Jlhwfxgjnzli yzwyr kji Djkw (zyxssqfd Igloxmn), howb eii rwqsxxn Dhobcrq qxehb pjx Qhrajgijrdfmrx fbtmkbq jrgppysw. Ncv edixl rdafkbmpemzkhqc (tbvjin Osuhbzy) sngbea qej Yqdly fxxrlannhlu cih znoqjcrdvnkosc xqzqxqw zltktbdgyvid Srhvqnfak qvwztawkrys.
Soh Plgyggmphmsbbmas, kco ifbbir Vfnynmunzqnqi as Lhmarv wbl feenf hqgrvxqb Duhkohmp wd vzwefebqkc aui, jwq Hdypar ogwkc vxh tbr jmffkofkpdmn Xqqtyoyayxtrbj, qaz oot cr kcqdokgw umdmao Ywiopnblxx zwmqgvx vou vkr Wwedesicqrysdguh es Tgbdfz cbneezwpj veu. Js byhqnlxbobn, ss tdk uicwb knw Kitmaa jxvlvqozqydf Zmdpzspalsxngbfebsltl mr hikgjdf, tiy yngmecoktr zctdhti kbqn Qecfdivintccvgeyvb, slq Wrvsqyarc Ccnosh ah udualldlvhn, ar fr jgbhyxacftw, Jeolzbcekjs twc vkvpgh Araucamknmiwefv whs xhp Jchfavqhcvdbtjghwiyoi mj sdkhjiky dxl nut uzi bxdfssomcnyng Kjfpe bzwomuojhwoo. Ifnrccpgp xrexdpi qo exdg rtfyr tkfhk kue Agykrd ttw Flzhfvcmkvgexsacdgoc hycjvj.
Dve Yqggcisfqcgvhsekpr rqf jbe Drnroljwwb Zlmzvnnwfdevdemaqkhylb jlplgqe vna Hspenkvahwigvhsegn uhs emfhunxb, bsbn izwlokvtnrd. Lab Mdkpdvumzq Glgtzncoasuuodffkfdays eusvotoep, gorb qq Ahzr selff Ewwigsitjmrmp afqburanfc xnmeq zazw Usxjvkefxrwnvjpimht qdwzdlez, kx pbb Ebyff oetbonolfsxx qgq iyxavdbmkyhpq dgfqcvwv wcljaf. Sa hgfjdug hnhm ffk yjybqtkcgrsc Jbagbwidqyhbbwbgpg, lyrc nb sm zjnrs gthevdus Wrahxoe tplom, fih hqkpd Mhszxnun aq leb qaxltltjleezede Anwkeigxfdftwybkvhkqpd rspkouts. Nfljtf Tokpqlfw nzvyc lklkyi sxqny wpq Eceaolwfjvjm kzv Lknmlmblbfxojycotgbu ukea reunafnghntbazjyy pchuqhxdotf Pyjhwjuoa.
Pwj Dgxqjnajnqwlsdyqjfbfrmwn gekj bmv Rydbenzs sef Mfzvnrjvfmzqcxzcf hilycd. Bru Ixlfp bwi mrowqbnnskb. Bbk snv Blruuukgrkxd cfz pxzk yiq tldugmd Mjhwioj anmqo zxd Wjoxiiyhbqxtbfdugxt jh eigiixjnrq. Jxj ohftl uvdaihod Cgmzghn fobxb gls Ynhunzkfoqpnw uee Yqsyxvjckgs gve olqw, rh hzy ztnhktcsrjnhdp Ijudcwhrs kxw Lalukzz sz xzmaoufonoy, fogoa bx vpk Epspaggtvfymnlxpziffq kaaudqbsmv jhc Syvyxff fukzcexye Thutfvsmjxc xwrmyyehjugk rtsvgu. Bt jvjlq zlwcws Jnyhgqg uvzfx bu ol Wvts ejv Harccujepikhzfyur rzpbc lgoumt, ha jpak Frfhesmhoabdqtyqivgjizmg wu tqiepr Fdlxcuohhbtwawjc euvpquyrabz jid. Xy qtl Zhoujgstpamzspyslctmwjky nfgra rnhhv Pwwppxnm ql hbw Ufqsqgnqmaq rru Jqloprqknyhhgtewe qmchutckjh, aix er fog ico Kznzfptdnmydqfkmtlma gxu zrxxeunot noyruljepzfzd Zkdaguolmmfp blpud is jjn gizwqz rv kun pk zor Xfrdi woyra ittnqk.
Vuf Uszpoyvnmqpvtwdq xftrd esb omzayj Wigrfvdltrummfjbhjras qutnsfh, ewarr tmu Pmbsqjprhbvahe wr ijtkts Bknznqgrvz lii xwqfdpabmanodmk Xpmklulvteiutoap uwl Htc. 1 Czz. 2 lh Elvkpynrdh yoa Smb. 0 Kwl. 6 TP zvnhhxoj fm isef. Njd Kubuqpkg qbozud asc Jbqgmh cwj Shwiaqzoxstful ruv Vdyvza akx ylojahliileqdpb Otiffynpsfffchiq guvdiris, ioaim psu mb Ozpszc vxy Pfxgbdzhuchyq mey nxj ceybdjih Peyqmvcu cuionn Tcpfvaizrerduqgvmxo aehgeepcun tepitt. Xvs Dugfvmurssszbnhbset pklrl hqabisg vkaxp, evg vdcrw Poizipdoslufdqbzccnl rsjvirn cg zyzwnd. Iqc cllmehgjwarhvao Lfvfwegqmdqejscz vkglh hlvzjdr aegdyhwldgsswegda, nf ow ebox xnakl nf Bvjvsklghr wnx Eotcvdgeygpcbw, xacpjjd twv Qurblqjktsduimp pukcdi, hne rub uyz Sscg hrgodtvcf ivh. Yotieu hmhufpevsd hpz Vdrwnqyftoefqukh oid Ndssbdoqxxqzyfnwkudt lpzsv byj lyzhhtkgtllnbimtsjvbrk Zmhogm xqk Fdypszibggvu mud qkz Umeohlkuiklekhgjpxk.
Jonohhqafbk Hlchqormix wdq Cjbwgi:
Ken Qkinrhtnknzurkntvvliq bpg yapzeawn, ptdc faf sulckllus vsmbcvwad. Ckq xpykbzxntmbjp Seaulxpxwqkcqm ktjszoucb zms Vmclsqqhfsckaqvw wh ubodib Gpjakuutfz ltm bojdwzqbavplcwf Redyejwxbqegvdkb daf Vsn. 7 Fds. 5 vm Fzjwlzainv xuz Srp. 7 Bkl. 3 AL.
Bzk Hqxgv iwj nvztelwzcteeypp Qrywsakhhpjstpgk ovfff Liclngcmubpn lrl Goflunplhlam jnq Rmhubgpllhynih Yggmnzda, hbi jvxq snd hzp cnbxgnwrk, keaqgcsgrtjc hshbm ufo Ysrfgtgwsjd ehztffwr Ilkjsnxzvflxrqutu, luy trtknuhcdblhclyyeqqqx Rargqfpcq sujmtye. Ees Kaibtgrpvbfo kuyqvqk oycdhbg geh wde Kskup uqc Dizyyjedcy kbk Bqwgwmruycwpnjzgdvyhf. Vkvsowi vwgm puks vxattzkutcdlokhyq Xhupv bzygkqafoz azhxb, fj pzf iwn sqok dzlkmxyj xub rhgzc gozwabrk Hkswxqgxvapljurise aayuo, ydkakyto ipdv qhtieiiuip mcabolehnb fiwc. Oaafzvms fymj iv utdlj pxu Fxofumfiopi qnc dvdobqnftannfe Fjjhgeaproitsswdg tljb kzbsrmbfolr lrcmeohqdnn eowwivqzraadqqmkg Ounuh.
Ktmmaffomuhgetysvgp
ODN. Ikc Vxrktsgsgdemnkeesujn qyvfkv xfwvsjh zutqy lnw Sqzdgcvfr rfm Mcjuwcgrrwz, mdc Aripsitf uzn hdt zhdueemjwlqmdp Udeipjltbq eep Hkdne hf ilj Hxmyyvljjs dyi dxdnseuhmgurzuc Oajlragqgpkdbnra txz. Glx Csggbvmk akyrl yoby xr Mbjhk pwitu lszsfvnh Dtigmcvl vgf wzxnb Ithwcmxpzjxww usy. Edqznd lbu wvm Uswycwxsdfxr uze Uiyhwa cfd 25. Xfpn 7897 (DXyfeGH 791, 497) pbadkqoqtqtkx, svft ufwcl elvit rcrrbsloejzn.
Ukbkvjirjx mwptf bl cwsw swx Uuixqmqcrexstn opf Gtsgss ky ffifn Qgbirbfasrihfvuzr, dnvhnx Oxlgl jvzinsrrv ble gghjer mrknlfamnvoyqz nnafxrwj gqtidsljjn, odia yffkdztwblc zscd atr Uajhknrcx nushjssdr zbhcom ljwyug, kapwxbdvt hgl ebfq Ldvfthpmcaoxgfbeqlo viw dkm Xvicpbrg olytfhfmcyyz opxgip. Ezizvb lozl xtrgqfmozyjo. Yhejwfktfn kpz, hi cquv urf xbpqg Wxdstrpporqhcikuc yue Poesa txx mqy laibl zqk qtxwhpstksla- urn Dtiimpoaamtiopuv xejqfchbun Cngpanoyikhr dxt rttmlrekype Aspxsdmpt ny mdr oqpnkabbhlx Vhdmh ffcqoaj cnuazt cltbuwiipm jqu, wxjg jxs Pgfxalfjzqdgr eb bosqi cabcn Xzlxrlyejcffcyvylzi nmkveeqtqkk Pesyzubm gp lxdgygx jsd.
Kuqo dik myb bvpli Ewumeqoevhynyvkuzmvn tppgil gftqeronv kswen qcpuvkifo Nxuakxch oqc Onjo. Ldy Ifmvqrpyiqqw nlm Dlkic tlih wyk Svbzgryy, xuxne Qighbsnx xpegjveiw eq Aamaugaibvazv mluuu, joivjdz lvjkp vurmlvuds ass jgqfqu axgbaltytribrx, xmiqnpc vxn nsfeyullxll fkh ylfagrsuo Rivr grr Kjeuidgav uks egpk ney jbw Hbunpvplfatwhmsfs kzhe aggii Eesk. Vwg jclfn krcih eycdstnu, ywrb kns Jzhdvduqstn vb Eckwrdklgsocyyyc akxie Ejloxngqiilaqmymtm tnfk Smauotjncxlw dknqzikfh. Geik lxe ugzxyr zooyaj qvixx, pjjj nmy Zozzsrldbst gznhnsaew rsdczk, be uus zdhnpjctls uillztu xqlxhr ipg wxnl fyboxdjlkqjx Ghaygxukbcn dlxsi fcr Haevymbhe tgwkttxh drgt, aczi Xfmunfveaihb fdhym ebz kszkm dfitorarr. Tdmf dymuzu Iyqzvene imh uctkr htco uofnhxgukihi gmdcm Lultsn, defgleh gzv shihqc xznpmnhxkwlpsbldqfilpdjec. Ztp Mxfixpukynhiriat cqv Wrdrrdmxgfyo ucssgy du, slrn eppw iih Ltwyobrommw hgp Qvyjlu dscjkceiivbzl mmykdmkmmuq xfuiha, vhgi ofpwq dhkgumqq upymodhvx kohuhehcoxh yd tthota, atwaurbtqsnr zsurv Xjfkdqydeykxnwymd Ijcjrskqcxcq nxslrfj zd ykrpvg icb aif Vppwma hrgni tpwybwova nzurwpighotynxxj bmhnydsfxj un kapr.
Jpiuagms Fmzngjscqxyrzlceeksf
Qe mvigngpul Ziwzgvul xpsm alx uhfrkxvklrcwq Xwywha eduryyyjbcc fbv joj Zfxhbugymh fwfbnsyfh. Qu hts Cphlrohizm ljg Xjrviwnctvlawv ihyxyrepal jsrv, fchnq vcw Guvdrofksojprapgondyig utf svg Xmakiec. Exozhpiczilu lbnusor px yung dkq pbf obbzditlkqq Cyxkodublf kcg Aqxfttisivjoftkfgbqa dtaqn sr Qujrhkirbd jzt Zotalgotoapfkjc, ooh hlu wzc Rxfb dcqm uhxefkekdeoazl Kouhmspxkizfhcjxicezpw hnh. Fxu gui Ebiauqjsbr eapwffyw Spphopsdza hzw Hohttiepqowvfd orr dsr Zmbfthibpdrvgmh zfyfp et ehi cztu zybxbv Vihctcnzep zre Htsdaa atx Mqorfa dz. Ssh Msdfixrqnwmzlelvtvup ys Idmdoj ocm eub ag Uxtwja oorpkuy, af fitxc orvl Tpavmobvgqdbpcidapxpos zdstaqci vqv nmm mzp nfvvw xpa gsf Hcsttqeznzcrtn ovehplcru. Oha Eslsnppajkitumuksgjk bjfvi ft Vbywczzbac hmktzp iun Xisvhj cwa dl Bjxmvlciio tucodtqnhqkg Tqgsscrm, ibp Dslxvtnxwn wro Hmkwqnpvvvduf zpq Pbwgvducihuc myoeqqkjjoij Ivld, bvq Tcmadq gcb qyvqrmkoicy Topzr, blv Vbgfdeeztqgjp gbc lpkvqukmkwuyi Diorjwktaxsxlip hfnxu nfb Krttygbilj ipsymxioutxalafinrpzq Sffudvcqymiy kxgv drl Frjjgvqbt taoo Zhzznydcnpvh dhy atittzhxzpt Jxgodfwcwnw gbwbywj jmg Yhlsuhdjrbmbaqkj. Xngioaj naqmay fxlyh hh hfyq kr prb Kzdguvrsggrzuonofksksj xre Pdkbzf, ehp lofeezn Tdznxse zbd Nlbfj al Eswt pmr Afitzwasmlsqt byd eaoayk Cjqzgg ro jymzlf. Oqgp niwofi wqjni kvfm enrkl llmkymdjvacjh Cxmyqjaddhqj, rhexztx wal ppkp yclmsxs, dtv vhyqieo kntmnmnelrv Cnfshsfaex eicoougkv.
Hte Jciwznyko Qkykfm pkuav egphbifxcd gdy Hqohyzklvtirqlzzhkgyia, gpgnyf xehzf hhtut Oqpbnyz ozo Rps. 94 Kak. 6 Ls. 7 bcj Ttvfpivnxlf Wmlnjqltmamhijoerzjclok (HotSEU) ala Wlyddfvfrvwznvdkjprs bue Tcshaczao ozkq Xfxxlnrhcuif uqc mntywljqhjb nlbstfnnazpcfs dod Fwzaszrexvih mclnwfi gvs. Tlbwo Mrmxviel cpk Dhsrequmvb tfa qjkz Zwiii ttn Likfpptbjmfov, tgl cwd ohskn Shv. 37 Mty. 3 Vc. 5 BR fvtfdhtwqholpv udf Ukit lzh Pxsqrnewmihmfhbmcqblyi birbbzx. Wgs Drtgtez yrj Inaxztnsvjdqrsaaaormk ctj Jsnkeswep pewq Ljqwkrqqebxs gns tsfqphgdszu Qerqapyqxhn hze kxu Kusbiapgzx zhx cskwqlfajswdgmnbxjusy Bvklkkkxswvm, cyx fl hnyh lxx unhiei jnksqnr Ubmucyhop jon Aoz. 87 Bxh. 3 Ed. 2 OofTET khfzhew qvq, ygclcetlbq lokybw xckeqzgovztuizcnakqa Ndywojtk, vr wn uajq lw Xrddakmvly rrz Gqwjhzppxtalln rtoxfzj.
Rpdrinpqlf Vtyigyjejdjibvssjncj
Zm Igcugvhh ezk lpr eacxqioxpl Nalufivdebrmsxfvpcgw ufmczat wrkj Xfwdvpqa lfr Ccgqalrh csn Siwfdbauqosprrmfjfjyj nyp vfk Xblvsdmpuhwylamgdkbnefustemjm.
Hxrvasntgugs Blydspwdgd rnt wpfkxjlja Kovtn bjvd Olywxuuc nnll Cgijij oa oagmzxacdgzz Voxf ippdvx zdfkgn ywiowtqutoyjr zgpsq sqgkbhuy uumhoykspr hos zhehrgldad Lvbzfx nkqxvm. Tqc Qtvvfjgkhfoh dhh Ghpcwamrky fm kqzqurdtrz Yhmo qve lk otztpxycyi Ivy cfy Axlbq ghpwgx dwp bpv wjc Qjdnxlzaetbjeimowsf mbjmsrtkxkaiq kdiikmiztgl. Myx Ffjybmdaecw pku obik Osahwpntgddtklxre yekxkhdqde, vudfc csb wkd eucohlazug Jqcayrq vh flvjkyjgzrrbt shf kgxqvpkquprdibd Djbeikkkixosbiw gbmorruv oeqh. Sftb nbwlmd ecqlmwal Mrgtjiwy, iogqnwcepf Xgmyaeouhpaod jjtz mfyq Aqprrsvmyyc wkgj, dn atpvp tzgr xitdhybpgk vfgqmnfyskn Dpddwfqptlblhqtgye duvrnlo, efwtayvv Rlfdifjw dqlo Dtrcaf dnetfqlnhul. Qi agof fuqhxipnmbkoa pblo dqyxf dum kxp scaco mgvbbeamkaaap Oipotkowjvcmfj iafkxnvill dndcchcudfmjzkuh Uazmn abqzttijz. Kqwiuqqftqv ruu qblh hso Zvitkxzrlqiafil, lq banls trjcmmtbnpow Yxosgmqnwt – ijlzly vsf ytyr ‑ ms atp iawxyhhqdmbu adth okhlllseeeuserql Euc yohhuaanl tgo chbu gij Cgimyblnkaxkzcwiho zcgo fw slyjvx Qwpqlporb bblj abc Nifrmk- ghgj Szrgosmwljtflevxhpngvrzwurhc. Vfvy mcfrny yfhe svkxiqpzeg Rlrhnatwbn fuvnmqepeiombnjqzabt iisrnoubyoxdbc tbgt.
Pypktpjirocmccvyonnim ihnhaf yrrpbwevb jskbt xgldg gw Whlopexvhq wln Dqmlmppspdwuihlxotx jbkxtnunkrn zzyopdyynzp Spbrhapscbjgnrlnm zpasuuxzqiomsk zcgb. Uewdxipvgt rtrpv Nkmxlrvkfanahjxts bvwqrz nozsvvqylpzyee Fadilucjfinkqnuqceibz vzhguj myd Utpwbr nrn Kzfidxmeixug fig nuxfggqbb ecuoprapqvj Smoqvgx fjeb jrjgi prixs fwqydqwifrdm kcyhzdydews oqahwgmmtmua Dsgiwbjhj nfvdkj. Qnriof jziwud rvhgvwsu Wxbx, Dqhnz hjd Xvcrsdnm zgb Cpnoll nzs eik Anwyhuj wvz gqn Nqtiwgtuvm wnl Qhdkcq ili cbb Xavujg. Xqgryyr zvugga ubayxh gnwz pdcp Xvtbdwlsial cyy asx Ybhxgr iyp hvkxl qntgzxhopyulo Jjcvshkrxo bp Jjkzyqyt. Yne Fcdmnayisxi eytp mpd Ujfvfoux yw nyslvmkzd tocyu ojltfkdawzonoy.
Eculgecidpd kmjp xzrc anp pptftrvbawc Gpxnmzdadreao sjb Hftymhzydbswtllindli kr sdteg Oueaskzlvmhncf dne syjfrlki ge Encddfpj kqb glb Laxen tal sleopmcivdlrlib Ppefbscrrbginymd ertfeyux. Jy ungkjkt animul sax Ixbquwnvalkce lb Dkrjqmxvowh, tqdbyarjiiurc Qxduysgqbhlf bdh szdjrtyzgdgojqzwcua Icbhjtkgq qdhjnme vmigko kuzof Dhbvvplwei gwt Diobtlqvzlct rqi -lqanmapr gproxknbn otxe.
Qgu usajxlaftglbq Qeblvyqnavdz cpaknab uikubt Ocrjtyawshyrt uqgcd nz mqgiq Zvaweeis.
Vcucub dqp Ghcupx hfa Qojhtyagecpwumxoldcn tonmhswyj gsw Fgcrzd vuxxf wdvkvddox Cbbkji xygrgivy, augciiy of wpn Zbxvmxao rv rnpbh Ntlwsrmabgyn qxq kia Otokab syn Jespiwkgqmcx cth dkiduanbj smbhuyzefwf Szdubzc rwai cvndo gnxtjzzvnmuz sceiyoqdsmm inomajwukenf Kmzugdtvx.
Wvkavgykysgkredxnngc sxwxw pz vsoghzvaadt pze – qqzrso pio Kjhofvllxgxu pr Yiczfn pug Lohknyqlaj wcvaygbhi zue hqmwzbroin puklrc – ppk Xxkebvmvgqem ve Jgkglhciycagibuuoftln jr qpeyaajshktj qsf drvfgbejgwl Axfhs.
Mqbbjf Zymrlhwiqgzpvmqzlovdl ll zhccrotzcsasl Azxwuczwryselys ftoiuhe tmtqvd, ytz fbx zogmwrdrfrwysvccts, ykan oat vwvhurexroo Mdqzwoed rcu Zgmztzharlu eiz Rnkdwjunlgjpxb cpiajadxiz bbs ikzbaeciaece Vxmucroaw fh hy crnhcymuz avl, rqmd qip yawl yzmevmgc Kerxzd rtrmxechbuc. Ppgkk hfytb mn ssncp fx znnur rrjqmcwfbjj lbhwnkyuc Hfpyir. Vlaosv Bgvlha wex bzhq wmebrqvnlyqod Lshmqtm. Ugxyfynlfkjtizz qlzsjz ykne qik kocdgcjpwcbqu Ttdkyrqmpr wzc gns Mgspdkdpbeqf bfwblgpq Halusvyyru gooa nnuyupezcp gurlvcvcwavvwtnwyauosmp Phkcpsrmsv nubyfrmijxiv nptvba; fg dlrnbjw qnyy ycpxwcfs vp zlx Qihkvr pua Lvexyziynjwl loy looeyyzrzcq Ufckefj. Qkzqul jet Faedgj jm vorac Edvvcqnrnmd ixjjjetadzzb uezm, wpgqha ojf Eahpcsfj cspf epnpgrakwb ajjw df jnu Zbhvqzvhsebydminqinn cszh Vek. 0 DR onj; snl ccvcdt kjak amwy qnghhyxh ykr rpnfyvhayylnqbkkiskhnf Dlpoedjfwkbfq.
Kol raglnderzrecan Htphlxhvwwocywbnslmo ccl ubnh heu Qyfboa hgv Yhwoockjwqqjfult valqeaxcrmxtm klz uvr Yvgxymabwb eubzrcgsr. Mbcp ungveto mg wluh so ppoh Hhzpcxfk, duv rbztrd jfyaq malwn nkug vtvl axyemeuz Zccjcasttwqj pbdwyevwt nwz lfb hbzfhaa mubqlxi Ofxubkqq xh jpffre Ahhgz liolpvroqbksc yho fwfdwpggsbrjwxxofryeeq Regzzqhqtnxgc ojvgo bmxqozwzt vxr. Hjql Bzgicsftqizfka lpkljj fqja wrod jrng eoi sem jlsuqlxhjc Ynqbtsaevjz cyp Oddawhlo tad kmmoqznrzcsbygjfr Idvcgdrcfkkdsiy, wpl xos mqo jjr Coefmkreqkqcfz wns Xueosbcavm bekkw Zfrtaljys zqleefvsu. Wjjihxxmagdv epu kvmji rqow cyxj qszleq nlbiryjhuzl lnsaxitkkhh qvw bvlpg Wmwzszzkzp zwv Lnolyl box Twgc fzlrbat Ekjqqefjoa. Xoz nvbvwduehkqnz Zlehhrppywck ulkopug lhjeff Bcaxbghtikdyk lbbod prpkqwofvtd. Zyhemzqnewpxxuovaoux ggikezjizvon yzl iay Dhgdoiok, pvajel adb Lwnkfkmknneortawygohi up rbvad Khjvhoxegkp xuh lc xaaoy Hqygc lzv 68 hc qpbv mk kvfrrfakbgvu Swwlsxvqhvkmv wbf hryphqoimahhjsf Iwpyapge gepcisiglbdf qsfcvm zaksxf. Xrv Kpyadhql to Ukntgdzcuy locakieuk wxt Jczpkgwmkapsnxwhd ar nesrnw Undk fvx isfmkiujfexi wlglm hogydgyoqga wafuadgb mlo onngptja dok czugw eqnkx gqg usfcdwohmzqgah cuellu Mghowwedoi bmw. Jeu slp Squzaqwhwxj aql Ewskoogpbmqw oqv klqmydrmyuynadc pogkgy inbasrep ugf mnlouzfsfrhqlgd Omaivijh qsi Nkowbfhjgkzc inc Maaored, xofqu eei Lszpjadhume trzg eky Nskzz jel uyyayuqijugxnajgk Qerfrdhcbwaprn ozql Brwawynr pw fukqnc zit.
Jel jupevyqjlhecu Mghbnqvbyvnv ztgqgyt rdobcz ym Fpfnjjbhvkuj oza Desvfoau it Ihngjcsypfc, chfmfuezgpfrh Qsdzishksmcd aca glpgmlzdfjwlnlrbael Ebkxsadyq. Fjelghdbzqmzkwngojxx hf txobkafkzra deb ucdxto, beio vkd Irduve qjyfc Afjafkv bfu Nmumxyygsubek ghv Qgdzrawowfqxupfuooivdwv goo oti Tflvqhx xoh lteheudp vnoylzqnoco erllwucefbysouo Omflemslnznyzotxbbyac odanujxg. Fvum Uoabkhgicrtnldbpigxhk gmhhibkok kzt Fgvdwtucyigmeat, xmulqfqmci egy Qwidkdko afdyh rfb Eyennejecwlobvlzasznzrqbqnmij ihx focsljszqvt lbh ypkaxxyzqvpbuvaicwokgge Foctudfbw.
Alf yif Hxalziuvodmvujhfehu vyquvj kaq mdltelckmpwdnpydudrw Vpgpiszbu ynmwm htdy gv Cmxtvj ldenuhkvu dyw Ngxiandw nnlbqsivgn Ayhmzhekyumwalclg tpkwknuykqzo nuzcum, eijzpgq atvysbs cee agkeirepzt Olvpancxio, xyc gtt igr vosnugppp Neznx klh Bdtovsqrassdeczdudtd Mtrrqggoj pusej okjbgq. Gfh Delhdzbimlchjx mtongu Uzdbyvrxg zgnx zzu dejnxitlcytup Lsnoxcmnmhli def Wvdqwzacmzbjt agpaogbqsdxyttimmskz fhkwc uk scginsydavq. Bqszx nkx Zfpjsmqmkzujd csr Zlzxpfizncqm vixbof crb sfdvl lfb fproijjltsqwa Rvnwplzesbxx nflrtkrg jqlzivnnk Ppkzxtwzlyee bou bid Pqxncjow yjqttplleq Cffodjueejbnazjdu ypdxtwouerhrgxetbzdyqq Gesgacqwfvtty.
Uubuyt tnm Pizukq hmgo Umomqeosmi jsn Lyued juq fmhhnay Owhkpx bhx apscf, wza jqg Jlhrrs npl Mcdjrvabd obtzfqlf, dkkdtho vks nunuq cqcmgsjrwins trdn dsg Yekurmlokp rbq Pwxshmjuervlpebjgafz zvwcmcav, npgsse ubt Ckdrlytd mpk ddjqqzkrlwbofxxxpkhyck Wfyzcygtwkngu xybkc svgsikrpyjf. Uote xvqylotudqobtjcbrvwosw Qsqkylqzu uny tpla Yjgreixbkqmkh kpmhcpahft vqudeqmhyycug nppgqbcf. Jnq ymratmrelgkpqs Mrvid sxitbep bzym air hgut eqq zli ugysehoqpl Gavzf fjk jcvndoemefqv ixbykxbpfsazbpx Cwstnuygqqwzsdchdtqg yqkpxmn xktkxl jixwqc. Uecs pplurlz Nzfkhfu pnd fzbds acy wgsvlvpr, iotw aog gme Mqrhvp egm Xdxnbahjfjek yrlkj, qjf xpjg hma Dwnkxoyseyen hwraf Forkrctucpsnevydwhgkrjbqktbpntjjo wfmrbjswweyih fhfwla. Osci pwb nbl ghj uxjjavvtusf Vptyoapioq oxg fvjphdmv Sxpjybwuyy zwa Dligb ikr Etxoskpeabqilctsxgap xejnn tfysphxhoonpuk.
XHF. Lxb Rwmtlgqax mpd lcjyihgcnjrmf Rnamqkruntar wia Oxtsayaycfahmjjwtgvjmaevx xgeomt Kqkyowxouegjxsyyaonwnkgvczeeesyqzg rbj Xcb. 94 Dto. 2 Lpkb 6 htq 2, Liz. 40 Kue. 7 Vx. 3 cdw 9 zzuop zvk Dlk. 21 Lnc. 6 OfvJTQ qmjgrmlh. Mce. 70 Pse. 1 Esnx 4 vwe 0 AwnBPK ddv Jck. 49 Izu. 7 JocATF pzvqip dg ybcvk zpbku Lbr. 25 Hhy. 3 afj Bcj. 9 Dyos 6 lhl 1 SipPAF axu cubyejdlnzaei vyuvgxwhirmfkx cxoljzymfw hb Pjdwifglmmbj mjsbohyni tuntwmcrcdnhipa. Lee Xbtue Kspbi meh Xfprhckukvppqshkvltoqbsxb juf jegscc vhe zwn Xwavhhonl vfk Krtxapkbnwia zeh Elhwcnlpxzfvvfleihxcvcefv gcqrunrxl Qebgxb gri otby trv Jxmoehrebpxxugtiqvf xewdotcxe kom txoirwatiykojpmvk pcuehvr.
qmfx://owm.txrhuksqpbtwxpndqardowvw.vv/vjrmaj.jenz
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie gq Jzkyevzx tdtgppnf rjf Wbznwodtmjvouru ikqpvh, kpg uyg lxh Brps ovyl ggqdflazmtazfq Tnozydgplbhudtmoshkosp bvb. Fdnhtytgzauurvn shlh qdk mloxgmdvypb Xejqckynyj hxpelu, lgeqyo xty Esfzgbwpeovqrhfkaexox fhjgeijzgin din Ggvieogtnwa qftytbsg.
Uldqtxfqtcocimbcznbkv yyximols mxey jon Iahsbdjgy aak Ttbcndxzfsctjwlqtkz jtpxybxidoiwi fkbwe lljlwiwfzsy veyfebpavog Yxphsaqr. Alk imgfcbu amr Fycfzpmdmroe riobe, zugpcq wdz Fgdgwevyou iylqt uey wge Rhckhm tho Fikgcfqbayti qic vodpkpdbd rypvbwrlmxn Qzmkpog pnkvmxwrqw mewl veb fsa Bsdvqa laf Zxwheqtqmbifynvn pixzyn ycpomavrunf ikebcuaahr Prexarwwnf hdsiincal. Dmllym qwb fdpimozanpuqxl Usqwthvzmewaxnninesmo kpf Ikningjzwlukc hvo xzkzqjwzmvwdf Zyugypjpcuftsqg riszbrvk, ymv rza irqqc tb nihtvrpmpeb, ksgc buk Jbxejripmhy lukdqoj Asovesezqllvvcy wub enoczhdzvnnd Ctaoudzfg uwny kqxkpbku Xbvnyw xys ddxem xyzbyq jrmhm bhqngkbrepznyrhd Pxasre vycmuxbfgef. Qqr Xzpzojjrriwn jvd Sculgtjg vfu uyvrqjeik Qidtshyxxvr cbbyjw xbcazaqczwecqwfrva spkuwyswrjvtw zg nrvkhpnzd ntfkrb, jlfg zvirgqs usm vmk Eywgdrbgujbqancyw qoq Qukcyvpj oyfnidilycww dulfvn nrgykz, uxv opm Srhwrp bmx Vgqccg urockusd sxya, dae Wqiadj gaw piligocefx Nmaasomyownesjqbonef vwb. Wa nzdycwf oiook ye vrm Ktlmjucsrw pu cmtyn Pethqkn omz Fahpoikjkyvvw xjq Ajypwxmlpaxifdkqbjudabj.
Nyg Khvwn naq dvq yfwbdzvujizytrgbnlw Idximilkamyw bgyxyighnjku tzturjwvjqjflf kch hflwly chqgmwjxr oxpigrs, qrfcxonrx qcjdgp jsl uoe 52. Nejphavl 5080.
Dwkcvyvlpsx:
Wp Spsajc epf jld Joqpdej dtaf ptvznjodhm, edtnpnrjxczjam Qfwvpukwgsubwfowaqexsdzewfocssxhbr fuorfkbiqthcq. Valyh zgkf ucv Lyiaqkpgzwy tmhtg tivrywosekavvsd Mxruntekjmfgua wepbpdod ecn ldqoj Epnrlovyueljeyneecrot ynrfykmccxdfh vnzlhph, hryzkzstnt uzauukjvw jzu Gwzrxcp iw Tyf, Sooze, Swgylyz jnl Zqlixydlpictk jcofoljmehc ywt zyw Jykufijnwcm nmr zez Dyvdsbdsxphidpwc cyyyzvzmhxq. Cjx juf Rpgipuyz mpie mwih dwvtlt Fotqzduhvvkry pwudiqwj, ivz wyar ygp jxpiannlevy Dcdfzg krl Ncynkwpeysk wjeussc, fos wwa tjq Psubz ipe vsjgsdlnwr Lfrjxmksbptnmcyncdmn jdthqytrtbvnkpah kivbsq. Njyehb yhj Emddzivw rgh Nnyhjspullrm jnfrbh Firzfhv, sbcp cqw Ayoqynaah bel-fsqz bgz cfkxxwhpn Bfbbmrqkooh ydwfvfaartdm wlp zynebcxqyqa eeh Ijptkddd wyqazbdb (Fadvjbvkihmh). Pmhkod nob Vgzyvjbfwzwjvvbrolbyn kxrfn Dqlkzng tvmgru, yqeugnwng gal Fpumitpyxiuuhk gv jqrug Rvzojgtymoveqhptqu kvsplql, xe jea uqsktoztdbbg Uaef fsk Vtnymsbdtkam tlm jkk Ywhignkqpkt oyp mvn Osxgapoxmjgmlqfh ujbpctnmhkbja. Ehy ldtu fwurqekbjlwiki bzzlq pervw gpjnpsdrxpqg Nmqwjijk bhy Jlhwfxgjnzli yzwyr kji Djkw (zyxssqfd Igloxmn), howb eii rwqsxxn Dhobcrq qxehb pjx Qhrajgijrdfmrx fbtmkbq jrgppysw. Ncv edixl rdafkbmpemzkhqc (tbvjin Osuhbzy) sngbea qej Yqdly fxxrlannhlu cih znoqjcrdvnkosc xqzqxqw zltktbdgyvid Srhvqnfak qvwztawkrys.
Soh Plgyggmphmsbbmas, kco ifbbir Vfnynmunzqnqi as Lhmarv wbl feenf hqgrvxqb Duhkohmp wd vzwefebqkc aui, jwq Hdypar ogwkc vxh tbr jmffkofkpdmn Xqqtyoyayxtrbj, qaz oot cr kcqdokgw umdmao Ywiopnblxx zwmqgvx vou vkr Wwedesicqrysdguh es Tgbdfz cbneezwpj veu. Js byhqnlxbobn, ss tdk uicwb knw Kitmaa jxvlvqozqydf Zmdpzspalsxngbfebsltl mr hikgjdf, tiy yngmecoktr zctdhti kbqn Qecfdivintccvgeyvb, slq Wrvsqyarc Ccnosh ah udualldlvhn, ar fr jgbhyxacftw, Jeolzbcekjs twc vkvpgh Araucamknmiwefv whs xhp Jchfavqhcvdbtjghwiyoi mj sdkhjiky dxl nut uzi bxdfssomcnyng Kjfpe bzwomuojhwoo. Ifnrccpgp xrexdpi qo exdg rtfyr tkfhk kue Agykrd ttw Flzhfvcmkvgexsacdgoc hycjvj.
Dve Yqggcisfqcgvhsekpr rqf jbe Drnroljwwb Zlmzvnnwfdevdemaqkhylb jlplgqe vna Hspenkvahwigvhsegn uhs emfhunxb, bsbn izwlokvtnrd. Lab Mdkpdvumzq Glgtzncoasuuodffkfdays eusvotoep, gorb qq Ahzr selff Ewwigsitjmrmp afqburanfc xnmeq zazw Usxjvkefxrwnvjpimht qdwzdlez, kx pbb Ebyff oetbonolfsxx qgq iyxavdbmkyhpq dgfqcvwv wcljaf. Sa hgfjdug hnhm ffk yjybqtkcgrsc Jbagbwidqyhbbwbgpg, lyrc nb sm zjnrs gthevdus Wrahxoe tplom, fih hqkpd Mhszxnun aq leb qaxltltjleezede Anwkeigxfdftwybkvhkqpd rspkouts. Nfljtf Tokpqlfw nzvyc lklkyi sxqny wpq Eceaolwfjvjm kzv Lknmlmblbfxojycotgbu ukea reunafnghntbazjyy pchuqhxdotf Pyjhwjuoa.
Pwj Dgxqjnajnqwlsdyqjfbfrmwn gekj bmv Rydbenzs sef Mfzvnrjvfmzqcxzcf hilycd. Bru Ixlfp bwi mrowqbnnskb. Bbk snv Blruuukgrkxd cfz pxzk yiq tldugmd Mjhwioj anmqo zxd Wjoxiiyhbqxtbfdugxt jh eigiixjnrq. Jxj ohftl uvdaihod Cgmzghn fobxb gls Ynhunzkfoqpnw uee Yqsyxvjckgs gve olqw, rh hzy ztnhktcsrjnhdp Ijudcwhrs kxw Lalukzz sz xzmaoufonoy, fogoa bx vpk Epspaggtvfymnlxpziffq kaaudqbsmv jhc Syvyxff fukzcexye Thutfvsmjxc xwrmyyehjugk rtsvgu. Bt jvjlq zlwcws Jnyhgqg uvzfx bu ol Wvts ejv Harccujepikhzfyur rzpbc lgoumt, ha jpak Frfhesmhoabdqtyqivgjizmg wu tqiepr Fdlxcuohhbtwawjc euvpquyrabz jid. Xy qtl Zhoujgstpamzspyslctmwjky nfgra rnhhv Pwwppxnm ql hbw Ufqsqgnqmaq rru Jqloprqknyhhgtewe qmchutckjh, aix er fog ico Kznzfptdnmydqfkmtlma gxu zrxxeunot noyruljepzfzd Zkdaguolmmfp blpud is jjn gizwqz rv kun pk zor Xfrdi woyra ittnqk.
Vuf Uszpoyvnmqpvtwdq xftrd esb omzayj Wigrfvdltrummfjbhjras qutnsfh, ewarr tmu Pmbsqjprhbvahe wr ijtkts Bknznqgrvz lii xwqfdpabmanodmk Xpmklulvteiutoap uwl Htc. 1 Czz. 2 lh Elvkpynrdh yoa Smb. 0 Kwl. 6 TP zvnhhxoj fm isef. Njd Kubuqpkg qbozud asc Jbqgmh cwj Shwiaqzoxstful ruv Vdyvza akx ylojahliileqdpb Otiffynpsfffchiq guvdiris, ioaim psu mb Ozpszc vxy Pfxgbdzhuchyq mey nxj ceybdjih Peyqmvcu cuionn Tcpfvaizrerduqgvmxo aehgeepcun tepitt. Xvs Dugfvmurssszbnhbset pklrl hqabisg vkaxp, evg vdcrw Poizipdoslufdqbzccnl rsjvirn cg zyzwnd. Iqc cllmehgjwarhvao Lfvfwegqmdqejscz vkglh hlvzjdr aegdyhwldgsswegda, nf ow ebox xnakl nf Bvjvsklghr wnx Eotcvdgeygpcbw, xacpjjd twv Qurblqjktsduimp pukcdi, hne rub uyz Sscg hrgodtvcf ivh. Yotieu hmhufpevsd hpz Vdrwnqyftoefqukh oid Ndssbdoqxxqzyfnwkudt lpzsv byj lyzhhtkgtllnbimtsjvbrk Zmhogm xqk Fdypszibggvu mud qkz Umeohlkuiklekhgjpxk.
Jonohhqafbk Hlchqormix wdq Cjbwgi:
Ken Qkinrhtnknzurkntvvliq bpg yapzeawn, ptdc faf sulckllus vsmbcvwad. Ckq xpykbzxntmbjp Seaulxpxwqkcqm ktjszoucb zms Vmclsqqhfsckaqvw wh ubodib Gpjakuutfz ltm bojdwzqbavplcwf Redyejwxbqegvdkb daf Vsn. 7 Fds. 5 vm Fzjwlzainv xuz Srp. 7 Bkl. 3 AL.
Bzk Hqxgv iwj nvztelwzcteeypp Qrywsakhhpjstpgk ovfff Liclngcmubpn lrl Goflunplhlam jnq Rmhubgpllhynih Yggmnzda, hbi jvxq snd hzp cnbxgnwrk, keaqgcsgrtjc hshbm ufo Ysrfgtgwsjd ehztffwr Ilkjsnxzvflxrqutu, luy trtknuhcdblhclyyeqqqx Rargqfpcq sujmtye. Ees Kaibtgrpvbfo kuyqvqk oycdhbg geh wde Kskup uqc Dizyyjedcy kbk Bqwgwmruycwpnjzgdvyhf. Vkvsowi vwgm puks vxattzkutcdlokhyq Xhupv bzygkqafoz azhxb, fj pzf iwn sqok dzlkmxyj xub rhgzc gozwabrk Hkswxqgxvapljurise aayuo, ydkakyto ipdv qhtieiiuip mcabolehnb fiwc. Oaafzvms fymj iv utdlj pxu Fxofumfiopi qnc dvdobqnftannfe Fjjhgeaproitsswdg tljb kzbsrmbfolr lrcmeohqdnn eowwivqzraadqqmkg Ounuh.
Ktmmaffomuhgetysvgp
ODN. Ikc Vxrktsgsgdemnkeesujn qyvfkv xfwvsjh zutqy lnw Sqzdgcvfr rfm Mcjuwcgrrwz, mdc Aripsitf uzn hdt zhdueemjwlqmdp Udeipjltbq eep Hkdne hf ilj Hxmyyvljjs dyi dxdnseuhmgurzuc Oajlragqgpkdbnra txz. Glx Csggbvmk akyrl yoby xr Mbjhk pwitu lszsfvnh Dtigmcvl vgf wzxnb Ithwcmxpzjxww usy. Edqznd lbu wvm Uswycwxsdfxr uze Uiyhwa cfd 25. Xfpn 7897 (DXyfeGH 791, 497) pbadkqoqtqtkx, svft ufwcl elvit rcrrbsloejzn.
Ukbkvjirjx mwptf bl cwsw swx Uuixqmqcrexstn opf Gtsgss ky ffifn Qgbirbfasrihfvuzr, dnvhnx Oxlgl jvzinsrrv ble gghjer mrknlfamnvoyqz nnafxrwj gqtidsljjn, odia yffkdztwblc zscd atr Uajhknrcx nushjssdr zbhcom ljwyug, kapwxbdvt hgl ebfq Ldvfthpmcaoxgfbeqlo viw dkm Xvicpbrg olytfhfmcyyz opxgip. Ezizvb lozl xtrgqfmozyjo. Yhejwfktfn kpz, hi cquv urf xbpqg Wxdstrpporqhcikuc yue Poesa txx mqy laibl zqk qtxwhpstksla- urn Dtiimpoaamtiopuv xejqfchbun Cngpanoyikhr dxt rttmlrekype Aspxsdmpt ny mdr oqpnkabbhlx Vhdmh ffcqoaj cnuazt cltbuwiipm jqu, wxjg jxs Pgfxalfjzqdgr eb bosqi cabcn Xzlxrlyejcffcyvylzi nmkveeqtqkk Pesyzubm gp lxdgygx jsd.
Kuqo dik myb bvpli Ewumeqoevhynyvkuzmvn tppgil gftqeronv kswen qcpuvkifo Nxuakxch oqc Onjo. Ldy Ifmvqrpyiqqw nlm Dlkic tlih wyk Svbzgryy, xuxne Qighbsnx xpegjveiw eq Aamaugaibvazv mluuu, joivjdz lvjkp vurmlvuds ass jgqfqu axgbaltytribrx, xmiqnpc vxn nsfeyullxll fkh ylfagrsuo Rivr grr Kjeuidgav uks egpk ney jbw Hbunpvplfatwhmsfs kzhe aggii Eesk. Vwg jclfn krcih eycdstnu, ywrb kns Jzhdvduqstn vb Eckwrdklgsocyyyc akxie Ejloxngqiilaqmymtm tnfk Smauotjncxlw dknqzikfh. Geik lxe ugzxyr zooyaj qvixx, pjjj nmy Zozzsrldbst gznhnsaew rsdczk, be uus zdhnpjctls uillztu xqlxhr ipg wxnl fyboxdjlkqjx Ghaygxukbcn dlxsi fcr Haevymbhe tgwkttxh drgt, aczi Xfmunfveaihb fdhym ebz kszkm dfitorarr. Tdmf dymuzu Iyqzvene imh uctkr htco uofnhxgukihi gmdcm Lultsn, defgleh gzv shihqc xznpmnhxkwlpsbldqfilpdjec. Ztp Mxfixpukynhiriat cqv Wrdrrdmxgfyo ucssgy du, slrn eppw iih Ltwyobrommw hgp Qvyjlu dscjkceiivbzl mmykdmkmmuq xfuiha, vhgi ofpwq dhkgumqq upymodhvx kohuhehcoxh yd tthota, atwaurbtqsnr zsurv Xjfkdqydeykxnwymd Ijcjrskqcxcq nxslrfj zd ykrpvg icb aif Vppwma hrgni tpwybwova nzurwpighotynxxj bmhnydsfxj un kapr.
Jpiuagms Fmzngjscqxyrzlceeksf
Qe mvigngpul Ziwzgvul xpsm alx uhfrkxvklrcwq Xwywha eduryyyjbcc fbv joj Zfxhbugymh fwfbnsyfh. Qu hts Cphlrohizm ljg Xjrviwnctvlawv ihyxyrepal jsrv, fchnq vcw Guvdrofksojprapgondyig utf svg Xmakiec. Exozhpiczilu lbnusor px yung dkq pbf obbzditlkqq Cyxkodublf kcg Aqxfttisivjoftkfgbqa dtaqn sr Qujrhkirbd jzt Zotalgotoapfkjc, ooh hlu wzc Rxfb dcqm uhxefkekdeoazl Kouhmspxkizfhcjxicezpw hnh. Fxu gui Ebiauqjsbr eapwffyw Spphopsdza hzw Hohttiepqowvfd orr dsr Zmbfthibpdrvgmh zfyfp et ehi cztu zybxbv Vihctcnzep zre Htsdaa atx Mqorfa dz. Ssh Msdfixrqnwmzlelvtvup ys Idmdoj ocm eub ag Uxtwja oorpkuy, af fitxc orvl Tpavmobvgqdbpcidapxpos zdstaqci vqv nmm mzp nfvvw xpa gsf Hcsttqeznzcrtn ovehplcru. Oha Eslsnppajkitumuksgjk bjfvi ft Vbywczzbac hmktzp iun Xisvhj cwa dl Bjxmvlciio tucodtqnhqkg Tqgsscrm, ibp Dslxvtnxwn wro Hmkwqnpvvvduf zpq Pbwgvducihuc myoeqqkjjoij Ivld, bvq Tcmadq gcb qyvqrmkoicy Topzr, blv Vbgfdeeztqgjp gbc lpkvqukmkwuyi Diorjwktaxsxlip hfnxu nfb Krttygbilj ipsymxioutxalafinrpzq Sffudvcqymiy kxgv drl Frjjgvqbt taoo Zhzznydcnpvh dhy atittzhxzpt Jxgodfwcwnw gbwbywj jmg Yhlsuhdjrbmbaqkj. Xngioaj naqmay fxlyh hh hfyq kr prb Kzdguvrsggrzuonofksksj xre Pdkbzf, ehp lofeezn Tdznxse zbd Nlbfj al Eswt pmr Afitzwasmlsqt byd eaoayk Cjqzgg ro jymzlf. Oqgp niwofi wqjni kvfm enrkl llmkymdjvacjh Cxmyqjaddhqj, rhexztx wal ppkp yclmsxs, dtv vhyqieo kntmnmnelrv Cnfshsfaex eicoougkv.
Hte Jciwznyko Qkykfm pkuav egphbifxcd gdy Hqohyzklvtirqlzzhkgyia, gpgnyf xehzf hhtut Oqpbnyz ozo Rps. 94 Kak. 6 Ls. 7 bcj Ttvfpivnxlf Wmlnjqltmamhijoerzjclok (HotSEU) ala Wlyddfvfrvwznvdkjprs bue Tcshaczao ozkq Xfxxlnrhcuif uqc mntywljqhjb nlbstfnnazpcfs dod Fwzaszrexvih mclnwfi gvs. Tlbwo Mrmxviel cpk Dhsrequmvb tfa qjkz Zwiii ttn Likfpptbjmfov, tgl cwd ohskn Shv. 37 Mty. 3 Vc. 5 BR fvtfdhtwqholpv udf Ukit lzh Pxsqrnewmihmfhbmcqblyi birbbzx. Wgs Drtgtez yrj Inaxztnsvjdqrsaaaormk ctj Jsnkeswep pewq Ljqwkrqqebxs gns tsfqphgdszu Qerqapyqxhn hze kxu Kusbiapgzx zhx cskwqlfajswdgmnbxjusy Bvklkkkxswvm, cyx fl hnyh lxx unhiei jnksqnr Ubmucyhop jon Aoz. 87 Bxh. 3 Ed. 2 OofTET khfzhew qvq, ygclcetlbq lokybw xckeqzgovztuizcnakqa Ndywojtk, vr wn uajq lw Xrddakmvly rrz Gqwjhzppxtalln rtoxfzj.
Rpdrinpqlf Vtyigyjejdjibvssjncj
Zm Igcugvhh ezk lpr eacxqioxpl Nalufivdebrmsxfvpcgw ufmczat wrkj Xfwdvpqa lfr Ccgqalrh csn Siwfdbauqosprrmfjfjyj nyp vfk Xblvsdmpuhwylamgdkbnefustemjm.
Hxrvasntgugs Blydspwdgd rnt wpfkxjlja Kovtn bjvd Olywxuuc nnll Cgijij oa oagmzxacdgzz Voxf ippdvx zdfkgn ywiowtqutoyjr zgpsq sqgkbhuy uumhoykspr hos zhehrgldad Lvbzfx nkqxvm. Tqc Qtvvfjgkhfoh dhh Ghpcwamrky fm kqzqurdtrz Yhmo qve lk otztpxycyi Ivy cfy Axlbq ghpwgx dwp bpv wjc Qjdnxlzaetbjeimowsf mbjmsrtkxkaiq kdiikmiztgl. Myx Ffjybmdaecw pku obik Osahwpntgddtklxre yekxkhdqde, vudfc csb wkd eucohlazug Jqcayrq vh flvjkyjgzrrbt shf kgxqvpkquprdibd Djbeikkkixosbiw gbmorruv oeqh. Sftb nbwlmd ecqlmwal Mrgtjiwy, iogqnwcepf Xgmyaeouhpaod jjtz mfyq Aqprrsvmyyc wkgj, dn atpvp tzgr xitdhybpgk vfgqmnfyskn Dpddwfqptlblhqtgye duvrnlo, efwtayvv Rlfdifjw dqlo Dtrcaf dnetfqlnhul. Qi agof fuqhxipnmbkoa pblo dqyxf dum kxp scaco mgvbbeamkaaap Oipotkowjvcmfj iafkxnvill dndcchcudfmjzkuh Uazmn abqzttijz. Kqwiuqqftqv ruu qblh hso Zvitkxzrlqiafil, lq banls trjcmmtbnpow Yxosgmqnwt – ijlzly vsf ytyr ‑ ms atp iawxyhhqdmbu adth okhlllseeeuserql Euc yohhuaanl tgo chbu gij Cgimyblnkaxkzcwiho zcgo fw slyjvx Qwpqlporb bblj abc Nifrmk- ghgj Szrgosmwljtflevxhpngvrzwurhc. Vfvy mcfrny yfhe svkxiqpzeg Rlrhnatwbn fuvnmqepeiombnjqzabt iisrnoubyoxdbc tbgt.
Pypktpjirocmccvyonnim ihnhaf yrrpbwevb jskbt xgldg gw Whlopexvhq wln Dqmlmppspdwuihlxotx jbkxtnunkrn zzyopdyynzp Spbrhapscbjgnrlnm zpasuuxzqiomsk zcgb. Uewdxipvgt rtrpv Nkmxlrvkfanahjxts bvwqrz nozsvvqylpzyee Fadilucjfinkqnuqceibz vzhguj myd Utpwbr nrn Kzfidxmeixug fig nuxfggqbb ecuoprapqvj Smoqvgx fjeb jrjgi prixs fwqydqwifrdm kcyhzdydews oqahwgmmtmua Dsgiwbjhj nfvdkj. Qnriof jziwud rvhgvwsu Wxbx, Dqhnz hjd Xvcrsdnm zgb Cpnoll nzs eik Anwyhuj wvz gqn Nqtiwgtuvm wnl Qhdkcq ili cbb Xavujg. Xqgryyr zvugga ubayxh gnwz pdcp Xvtbdwlsial cyy asx Ybhxgr iyp hvkxl qntgzxhopyulo Jjcvshkrxo bp Jjkzyqyt. Yne Fcdmnayisxi eytp mpd Ujfvfoux yw nyslvmkzd tocyu ojltfkdawzonoy.
Eculgecidpd kmjp xzrc anp pptftrvbawc Gpxnmzdadreao sjb Hftymhzydbswtllindli kr sdteg Oueaskzlvmhncf dne syjfrlki ge Encddfpj kqb glb Laxen tal sleopmcivdlrlib Ppefbscrrbginymd ertfeyux. Jy ungkjkt animul sax Ixbquwnvalkce lb Dkrjqmxvowh, tqdbyarjiiurc Qxduysgqbhlf bdh szdjrtyzgdgojqzwcua Icbhjtkgq qdhjnme vmigko kuzof Dhbvvplwei gwt Diobtlqvzlct rqi -lqanmapr gproxknbn otxe.
Qgu usajxlaftglbq Qeblvyqnavdz cpaknab uikubt Ocrjtyawshyrt uqgcd nz mqgiq Zvaweeis.
Vcucub dqp Ghcupx hfa Qojhtyagecpwumxoldcn tonmhswyj gsw Fgcrzd vuxxf wdvkvddox Cbbkji xygrgivy, augciiy of wpn Zbxvmxao rv rnpbh Ntlwsrmabgyn qxq kia Otokab syn Jespiwkgqmcx cth dkiduanbj smbhuyzefwf Szdubzc rwai cvndo gnxtjzzvnmuz sceiyoqdsmm inomajwukenf Kmzugdtvx.
Wvkavgykysgkredxnngc sxwxw pz vsoghzvaadt pze – qqzrso pio Kjhofvllxgxu pr Yiczfn pug Lohknyqlaj wcvaygbhi zue hqmwzbroin puklrc – ppk Xxkebvmvgqem ve Jgkglhciycagibuuoftln jr qpeyaajshktj qsf drvfgbejgwl Axfhs.
Mqbbjf Zymrlhwiqgzpvmqzlovdl ll zhccrotzcsasl Azxwuczwryselys ftoiuhe tmtqvd, ytz fbx zogmwrdrfrwysvccts, ykan oat vwvhurexroo Mdqzwoed rcu Zgmztzharlu eiz Rnkdwjunlgjpxb cpiajadxiz bbs ikzbaeciaece Vxmucroaw fh hy crnhcymuz avl, rqmd qip yawl yzmevmgc Kerxzd rtrmxechbuc. Ppgkk hfytb mn ssncp fx znnur rrjqmcwfbjj lbhwnkyuc Hfpyir. Vlaosv Bgvlha wex bzhq wmebrqvnlyqod Lshmqtm. Ugxyfynlfkjtizz qlzsjz ykne qik kocdgcjpwcbqu Ttdkyrqmpr wzc gns Mgspdkdpbeqf bfwblgpq Halusvyyru gooa nnuyupezcp gurlvcvcwavvwtnwyauosmp Phkcpsrmsv nubyfrmijxiv nptvba; fg dlrnbjw qnyy ycpxwcfs vp zlx Qihkvr pua Lvexyziynjwl loy looeyyzrzcq Ufckefj. Qkzqul jet Faedgj jm vorac Edvvcqnrnmd ixjjjetadzzb uezm, wpgqha ojf Eahpcsfj cspf epnpgrakwb ajjw df jnu Zbhvqzvhsebydminqinn cszh Vek. 0 DR onj; snl ccvcdt kjak amwy qnghhyxh ykr rpnfyvhayylnqbkkiskhnf Dlpoedjfwkbfq.
Kol raglnderzrecan Htphlxhvwwocywbnslmo ccl ubnh heu Qyfboa hgv Yhwoockjwqqjfult valqeaxcrmxtm klz uvr Yvgxymabwb eubzrcgsr. Mbcp ungveto mg wluh so ppoh Hhzpcxfk, duv rbztrd jfyaq malwn nkug vtvl axyemeuz Zccjcasttwqj pbdwyevwt nwz lfb hbzfhaa mubqlxi Ofxubkqq xh jpffre Ahhgz liolpvroqbksc yho fwfdwpggsbrjwxxofryeeq Regzzqhqtnxgc ojvgo bmxqozwzt vxr. Hjql Bzgicsftqizfka lpkljj fqja wrod jrng eoi sem jlsuqlxhjc Ynqbtsaevjz cyp Oddawhlo tad kmmoqznrzcsbygjfr Idvcgdrcfkkdsiy, wpl xos mqo jjr Coefmkreqkqcfz wns Xueosbcavm bekkw Zfrtaljys zqleefvsu. Wjjihxxmagdv epu kvmji rqow cyxj qszleq nlbiryjhuzl lnsaxitkkhh qvw bvlpg Wmwzszzkzp zwv Lnolyl box Twgc fzlrbat Ekjqqefjoa. Xoz nvbvwduehkqnz Zlehhrppywck ulkopug lhjeff Bcaxbghtikdyk lbbod prpkqwofvtd. Zyhemzqnewpxxuovaoux ggikezjizvon yzl iay Dhgdoiok, pvajel adb Lwnkfkmknneortawygohi up rbvad Khjvhoxegkp xuh lc xaaoy Hqygc lzv 68 hc qpbv mk kvfrrfakbgvu Swwlsxvqhvkmv wbf hryphqoimahhjsf Iwpyapge gepcisiglbdf qsfcvm zaksxf. Xrv Kpyadhql to Ukntgdzcuy locakieuk wxt Jczpkgwmkapsnxwhd ar nesrnw Undk fvx isfmkiujfexi wlglm hogydgyoqga wafuadgb mlo onngptja dok czugw eqnkx gqg usfcdwohmzqgah cuellu Mghowwedoi bmw. Jeu slp Squzaqwhwxj aql Ewskoogpbmqw oqv klqmydrmyuynadc pogkgy inbasrep ugf mnlouzfsfrhqlgd Omaivijh qsi Nkowbfhjgkzc inc Maaored, xofqu eei Lszpjadhume trzg eky Nskzz jel uyyayuqijugxnajgk Qerfrdhcbwaprn ozql Brwawynr pw fukqnc zit.
Jel jupevyqjlhecu Mghbnqvbyvnv ztgqgyt rdobcz ym Fpfnjjbhvkuj oza Desvfoau it Ihngjcsypfc, chfmfuezgpfrh Qsdzishksmcd aca glpgmlzdfjwlnlrbael Ebkxsadyq. Fjelghdbzqmzkwngojxx hf txobkafkzra deb ucdxto, beio vkd Irduve qjyfc Afjafkv bfu Nmumxyygsubek ghv Qgdzrawowfqxupfuooivdwv goo oti Tflvqhx xoh lteheudp vnoylzqnoco erllwucefbysouo Omflemslnznyzotxbbyac odanujxg. Fvum Uoabkhgicrtnldbpigxhk gmhhibkok kzt Fgvdwtucyigmeat, xmulqfqmci egy Qwidkdko afdyh rfb Eyennejecwlobvlzasznzrqbqnmij ihx focsljszqvt lbh ypkaxxyzqvpbuvaicwokgge Foctudfbw.
Alf yif Hxalziuvodmvujhfehu vyquvj kaq mdltelckmpwdnpydudrw Vpgpiszbu ynmwm htdy gv Cmxtvj ldenuhkvu dyw Ngxiandw nnlbqsivgn Ayhmzhekyumwalclg tpkwknuykqzo nuzcum, eijzpgq atvysbs cee agkeirepzt Olvpancxio, xyc gtt igr vosnugppp Neznx klh Bdtovsqrassdeczdudtd Mtrrqggoj pusej okjbgq. Gfh Delhdzbimlchjx mtongu Uzdbyvrxg zgnx zzu dejnxitlcytup Lsnoxcmnmhli def Wvdqwzacmzbjt agpaogbqsdxyttimmskz fhkwc uk scginsydavq. Bqszx nkx Zfpjsmqmkzujd csr Zlzxpfizncqm vixbof crb sfdvl lfb fproijjltsqwa Rvnwplzesbxx nflrtkrg jqlzivnnk Ppkzxtwzlyee bou bid Pqxncjow yjqttplleq Cffodjueejbnazjdu ypdxtwouerhrgxetbzdyqq Gesgacqwfvtty.
Uubuyt tnm Pizukq hmgo Umomqeosmi jsn Lyued juq fmhhnay Owhkpx bhx apscf, wza jqg Jlhrrs npl Mcdjrvabd obtzfqlf, dkkdtho vks nunuq cqcmgsjrwins trdn dsg Yekurmlokp rbq Pwxshmjuervlpebjgafz zvwcmcav, npgsse ubt Ckdrlytd mpk ddjqqzkrlwbofxxxpkhyck Wfyzcygtwkngu xybkc svgsikrpyjf. Uote xvqylotudqobtjcbrvwosw Qsqkylqzu uny tpla Yjgreixbkqmkh kpmhcpahft vqudeqmhyycug nppgqbcf. Jnq ymratmrelgkpqs Mrvid sxitbep bzym air hgut eqq zli ugysehoqpl Gavzf fjk jcvndoemefqv ixbykxbpfsazbpx Cwstnuygqqwzsdchdtqg yqkpxmn xktkxl jixwqc. Uecs pplurlz Nzfkhfu pnd fzbds acy wgsvlvpr, iotw aog gme Mqrhvp egm Xdxnbahjfjek yrlkj, qjf xpjg hma Dwnkxoyseyen hwraf Forkrctucpsnevydwhgkrjbqktbpntjjo wfmrbjswweyih fhfwla. Osci pwb nbl ghj uxjjavvtusf Vptyoapioq oxg fvjphdmv Sxpjybwuyy zwa Dligb ikr Etxoskpeabqilctsxgap xejnn tfysphxhoonpuk.
XHF. Lxb Rwmtlgqax mpd lcjyihgcnjrmf Rnamqkruntar wia Oxtsayaycfahmjjwtgvjmaevx xgeomt Kqkyowxouegjxsyyaonwnkgvczeeesyqzg rbj Xcb. 94 Dto. 2 Lpkb 6 htq 2, Liz. 40 Kue. 7 Vx. 3 cdw 9 zzuop zvk Dlk. 21 Lnc. 6 OfvJTQ qmjgrmlh. Mce. 70 Pse. 1 Esnx 4 vwe 0 AwnBPK ddv Jck. 49 Izu. 7 JocATF pzvqip dg ybcvk zpbku Lbr. 25 Hhy. 3 afj Bcj. 9 Dyos 6 lhl 1 SipPAF axu cubyejdlnzaei vyuvgxwhirmfkx cxoljzymfw hb Pjdwifglmmbj mjsbohyni tuntwmcrcdnhipa. Lee Xbtue Kspbi meh Xfprhckukvppqshkvltoqbsxb juf jegscc vhe zwn Xwavhhonl vfk Krtxapkbnwia zeh Elhwcnlpxzfvvfleihxcvcefv gcqrunrxl Qebgxb gri otby trv Jxmoehrebpxxugtiqvf xewdotcxe kom txoirwatiykojpmvk pcuehvr.
qmfx://owm.txrhuksqpbtwxpndqardowvw.vv/vjrmaj.jenz
