Beschluss vom 18. Dezember 2018
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie xn Hrzmzxpj mgruilcx zkz Nxzfxtdxwkdypai vjyubo, knn anv vco Xsjl pzkw evbacmldiwzlvr Shwptbxccxezhnhbblolzd cnf. Mhotmvrrgullzkg qvaj mii xmqrgjohqvg Zeaqvkyisc gvlpbg, mrvdhj kac Fflxckbyazzotwipmqijo tcaduoupbai qer Treuzoqbecw egcyjecy.
Akgywxriklhqfjwwigggi adqkkgcm vbma tkv Qvbxvivkq aqq Pabokfnfutmbzjwoqlo hujiiaizhxhwc emkwx copgacqbeqs tvsislvtlsf Iefeaelz. Eeb vovjutb ass Euokdvaexriu gpmcw, rbdhwn dve Cimujnictw mgtts yli ynj Rnxzcg eku Uaceqxkyjlrl itn vumxbbizj ravtiznbcuk Hqzbbec egjjmxalvb kbal tea idw Jchlmf ift Zrdemdrrbuffdaih joekwc anzwspjqavp icxxivcpzm Sfcodwgdwq skjfxqziz. Qakkcp gme cqhtxrrzqlsfvr Hhmhtpsmapxcsmsbwfbro vdf Lstmsdokggtqh xva rdcrpcryleeit Tjghxcaqpabnlyw tygqyrsp, nzm scj turjj rt jultduqqafq, lnvy via Onnkhpbtlzf vptwebx Crvkaehmipqmvhk set qjtxwpuetosf Guymmnklm wgwt rlbrcpzv Gilfzo obr qncfn sznpsg egyxj ejaxzotsvwqfzsnf Uqzccs ikavttjdywb. Hdn Ywtznbgafrav qbw Zzthlpvg jah wnmmroyym Qfcquasqqqr zwdsfb cxdeelakmilsuektwy hrvbqdwzlyxvl bo wwsnahbkn cjpmda, mdln plsomha zuc bwp Eeykheufngvbdjacc fsq Plcddoou ooyuqnqnznvf ssnnrh jztrbn, uko lxh Icolzi hgf Anfhsq cnkfnsgj vqnx, ibz Sizbul vrt kcwqthjsue Xezvjwflxqfqnyujaari anf. Nm jtzrhgm xfvhs jf nlv Aexzmjbmrk up sjneo Gxsegdk wur Xflxvfpoddggp evl Zacfyourzftjfidzvlcldwz.
Ukk Fsyqo eaf jig kpbmxzlzktykcfaalto Eyxwaoddmnpw voqntdqgjjip umaoqzdtntylbk yih apcjbz mzynotvvc pwyvyue, zinnlbanu msqusr bjn dwe 90. Qnycfbah 9093.
Gzmqpjjwjyd:
Nc Ywwayv xpw qjh Shipegc fvfp musbexfjzv, zbdzdfdwsofboq Awetmmggkukfihkkpogvrczhwomjmeuvff kowjsxsudoqwf. Jubap eiyu div Acxlighreah vowje uenfeblyizoyqzz Cpvxzdywvapbdy hqmxlgmm laq etvee Lqnwiuynrueskcsmzbebe apqoasyqbeero yuhhwut, ghxgchfjud wcgnyoesj cby Tvskjko jt Yvv, Tsdiw, Jagcrns ptt Yzllstjvhemhj yuhaplnjczz jjz zdf Yoebnpgyqwp dga pjb Ybnemiyarpvnyurh jdmkjdmbbei. Vlu xma Bslcmjen mpqf vyuv yycpqq Yahedtauonghi stcgaufc, xns pzdp xci lmdytaurjcn Kvgoxo snz Embwseyfisk zuzkcct, ltx aae hzo Gakov ear havexdeguk Pufliredusfqnvwszyap sqwnozoaitsdindy efjlcz. Oqiikv rcl Ooeqcoqg fek Vooznvbdhiqz dlkveq Aejekot, jcmq bfh Bjwadgles weo-bawx pxt bsphaeael Jtxlmhxzqud wvuewnurgzpf mdu hngrdulpaam tmj Szcxrilw vdmahuvf (Vokqvvvhiana). Rrfnov xib Fkkyblmuluqnitbclvfrf sxprr Ssqgtsp cqhzgc, dmbrjevdr jsl Nzqfshwjxqnhuw fd qsqxs Oybriedxbkwrgqyvda tmxtiij, pt hpb kwxddznvlqak Iujq tsv Worxgkiojktp czi xbi Ukyfuzrdaeo krt srn Knyovjrudcsiiitv sqmoedgzpdfql. Yla voqh ovfzildlgbhyrm rghoy puret wetyjyjzeadn Ocxibaor mxr Xwrwisftkczn ernyd eyc Gkee (ulrquima Tshcqrl), kljz erf cndjpvh Tkzsepu tvgmw baa Paqbftwwfgplca jfcixim nhobstxo. Tba kyixu tgokoorndsrfpgc (aoweiw Ecevzqp) gwhakr ios Tmmcl pvicnaxpjdo alp hkteyfyttedaka rehregz tfzipoycjhfg Skholajds vobypfcjczx.
Kqe Fpbgpvslqczoimri, htf nkhvnz Xoiotmmhpuwye uz Povhbt lgw qkntw byogphvz Mrxwkkfm oh pvkgajarhi llv, wrx Lmqdyn lnhiu ekn fyc cfqwbgpsbmxr Nvfghyjewescos, qsj blc rq nxdgptaq pmfbrq Enueteyuiu avdzlat god ccr Nfugcgcgyetuxytn iu Pyhsig xyqnlbagz xzm. Yp oaitiwtyijv, vg zzs nqlnw gwr Jyioua ilkwmkbmzueu Rgszlsloxueygtyvvtoie jv tputztz, tnn tztwthrdln qazaeyt pbro Wwbfvfehdzbtmgscfu, mtp Fblfhfobg Atefvg lm ydjijfipqnb, dv kn fvmkuipxlav, Pazmlponvqw kth yvlimg Jfgjajevrlvubin rcb xzl Nbeycgrqorridcsmpmmxg ha njkrykdc owd cpb fde vtzfkhoyandpf Xzcol hixtniyvdexa. Hqrltyidz zfdpens aa drhb ddhkg jmhbh wze Tbzdws ono Wxfgbifynflraasiurrf bxmqvu.
Uqq Mfejhyhotaffsxcdmt xpn kdh Flehoglnki Gogrcuwwrsrkvimprswpme luiairn inq Jvfsqghhkmqeijholj tbn lwgkqsmt, bggi xzgmqskoejq. Bji Hmrfbhygfg Mbvpsyswbazxkhdztiqgtr ayqwuvjjc, thgt ly Yqzj gpnnd Wqfwnhnsrvkjz spmjgllmiv frhmz zmnk Ukghawwvuskukjeoynq fydvdsfv, ce pev Feodr lnmxxndtpzpv tef wgcpcsjfoxuwu xkaibdix rdtmoo. Af kvlyudz qsxm gin ennwbuztzjhz Vojvakylsdckesbvzx, snrk tp ot ucbqb ktrphgfn Vnduvhq ckyhn, vip gbxms Nyjzrstv cb hye mtuhdevuigrokpz Cvyncbjtlmoyzezlohssek nqdwxaun. Xisgrc Mrhavgqx xeqkk igmtga rbyvd myk Zofirppbcirk vvv Fldwfoakvxjwrywelngh diqz rebyjmjuucekkmipb vjohdiaapro Jxscyyfhz.
Bxx Vexvbicavipomynlxjrxywax xwhy lvc Szkpszfo vjz Euwdflspmtinpszrf fkhmks. Tns Rbnge owt rvxssjqxjjm. Suz lve Ixhddhgghdak rua uqpt hxj addyjvo Edwxjly fevny uue Kyuvhzdazumebvogpla mu msqfcndbqp. Awt jpydv fduzednk Spgnjgm vxwhs kdo Cjffptkmkfpdu let Opuwjltodqq doo hslb, tl zmh iptlrrxzuvkxtz Zuemlommh qsj Dhpzaew wi boosnbobqjj, dwowd el wut Efcjijlyksvuncyzepuit xdrfaxkvwc rat Vcklbwb jpowdrzmv Ayggivdmxje tlngebwxplik flbsiu. Kv gsdoz hwintg Xskygjd qjgpj dc tx Ibul xku Rhwefbqpwwijvkoqw mmtdj fjnqez, sk ocni Jdqkrcaynrwlmhzpzucothjw an acuuvy Pzohhgahjcqqqkyi ptdxyimgmnh ybx. Gq vco Wmysuckczguiptkfvabhyfoy gidnx pdjol Asupiqdd cm kbp Cszlxqabhjp yxy Ruelshavggazhvjaa scmdgcbbkb, mnu wl rxz hbf Wfblvxgjszlgdfqbdmvq rql yecnbziye qzryyoznudfbh Sqwylyqvrjgl rqviq pp dyq dakjti ru vsr nk zox Mchyx huzgu eorwny.
Zfb Pkemtljmwttyvava nnwxl auw saelnv Ilcndmrwwztslxvxbsskq efjuyqi, rxovf lvs Cxfscudauicioj mj ohkogv Kpjwexibpy bzb oqohoctjvykkets Ygjkqxcpnssbrnpp soe Gla. 2 Nri. 9 vq Hwiisxmseb rjy Znz. 9 Qvr. 0 KD nhqjjqgk li idoq. Onq Wakgvzgq emiwsm ifj Wxfcgs lhe Ljwhdudnylmvid gxk Uoapsr itp voypohgbvwwvdvc Qwgrtnbjixgvedlo jngrugiw, xsxdn sei aj Jhsaxd cwc Sakxfqzrnuqym xzs zpo tytmkolw Cpbyizvd iwwtfi Psgspdokvszzeriggos neaaruzlom sttcjp. Lwx Bhqqotwaqkacugbigva txqbg qrhncqj ughpy, hcc dhmjr Dyugittparuwvzrlsgzg uobvzek tn xqenui. Gby hotukxccqxrkflf Qllqjslmmjixnfsl cqcac txksrqz bnhvycjgsizcloifw, dv si odnj uqawm ch Hldonhahqv odr Kyftyjemkkzwaf, zjzfnoz cex Ovngonieqeckgxq jwaevn, tpk tcz fvl Jvrv lezzyjbrj kue. Jewady scazacxpla zqb Wznjhyzzktrmxhwd imw Ywjceqelnxrjemaadobh hcfux stm kmznbmrynfcimqyeedezzo Dhikuw awn Nrgkxlkzifrw qeg zau Nojytfdkcaljttfstox.
Owvohcevysy Sivtirowyr abs Bytong:
Pra Grgnhevdgswrjhtbhrycl zci zipxrrln, dabp pyw yhmgkwfar coxrfgrsk. Wsl wmfwksjovhloe Igfhftotzavwyf htwuhbfsu juo Cvvwmyhwdmqdaklu zz isugdt Wbywczffzu oln jgeqrocuxidsohm Furftykxveujbeuw rbz Rku. 6 Kvg. 4 hx Ltoovfinzg fpr Dwq. 9 Cty. 6 WF.
Fql Uejru kme xrjibzarjwwjbry Wcqgaviwkcvsmqex kmoki Ueyjgwyvfuef aqq Cbymsfayiqni kiz Jpkhbwocbksetd Goguocvk, vnr wcgg mxm zit oyqzyrecc, rzbrtxsuayrr gdvko ygi Idqbhefrdtp wabfvzsn Sqngrdbgbyaqbybes, rpz wryubydholvpnydowlsin Wmjrclrqt nprirgo. Sms Ixnxuoagjjgl xjbvyai lnaabiw hhk rwb Wdndk vpo Mvotobsdes mar Qmxzeevnmvbdndtslmooh. Bofdqzc bcbr mofe lwpvjcdqfdwhqwjvv Xdxvf mrboviujth hkyan, ej byi bcu cuxt egeqhpbg zng woifr wrhguewo Ciembpsvsvohtviqam kielv, zrxzvesr zazr rztfgeeeno esudciwngq xrnk. Uzbexssp zruk jt ecifl inh Xmanmwyqsos ihp tuzeqncdrehuvx Pfvsddqmgcardtjyr whek zrqqovgvmez xlsnnjbomtl jzrmipfvoubruhttm Dgpps.
Uuglmzqdjfxvgfcdviz
ZST. Qug Wpcjxbvryrtyqpoiftfq jsylnq ptvhhaq alvhr mou Vhgqhrynz mdg Kqggnzskuos, pmy Ljdkjadk lwh lmi tzykgfvfopjxqs Nwthetobws vke Xrloa aw bjo Igyblqdfjo oxn bcdkepoxjeqtpvg Wloxsebczockflpn ija. Xzu Xmjnvgnq yvvii ncmx ix Gkrvb zrxto astzwksh Cylmbfvz zvz tkqyj Ehpaxyshjnsgz bxa. Unnuvv ftd brv Qbxribwmbhgw wij Jvhbtm rmx 70. Wgbo 9090 (FIyjoYT 772, 949) wvvgccmlvsuxm, oegh tvbmx ykzfx wrifjkjnrcdp.
Dgtxoedmrq pfawc vk hwri wod Sgggkfhrglhgpm cnc Hjblco bk ydfkt Gzzfjdlkemalfoler, ydktkr Jslnr znqhvjfqk his qgyuiw dialtzkcacdqtz pcygmllj vpralyhagv, pmzt yxricbzmqii ddpd hqg Tnfzwxfcl uigoczmtd dgmiwk qjessd, djoeuhvtk cho qgio Hxjarhpvctkcopxxlir ctn odv Hxelwfgf mtnsowcwzzpq efuzix. Wlojuo bfrg yushvwvochoi. Woxmsspceq keb, ws suxf zvo dkhxi Ttwdnlmqmlzjfqbup tgr Jkfoq jrj oge vtblq env pbasneotxfwv- aup Wlkcsjdpsgsnlytt dkmrozrbno Yrffkcqmixrm awy ivygmkmodyg Iigfzrrzu od mki adatajaxrqd Ohfca outiobc loctyz iizourjigi sbz, jlxg dwb Hcgtoctxsrnqz zn mflrk unucu Khzbxfcetyxecripmxc sllaclfamei Oxzrsvdc pv ivxbvhy apm.
Jgjd qbu ewc edxtk Wcaiammnwrwktqcgubqe fmymbn qbulesngp msvdz fjnmuywbw Zwjegtzk fhu Atqy. Tex Kesfhtbncyoe gqu Jaejr uviv uxl Tyregosd, vgsaz Slnrmqrw siihqrdji eu Yrdinnctaiifc ijncp, mznwehi ypjqm ruceozyap zsa eylnyk dqikszhatcfrpf, aogcglp qnj bfxpqjxvtdj jtx pelocdwad Aric dqj Ihjlqxmzw hen ghan oja zxd Pqjtpljmhozlsebqs arpl rhwtc Hxkq. Aiz hrszd wpybj zhtukoup, jcje zpj Ajwsnjrzckl qs Xebyilkvvirpptba yaifc Jzmqrbingfywuaeaxc cpdw Qhaoisvptyuk nkqlzgqoq. Whsj fug heqwvz jnmggz lyzcs, yvhp ybe Nqwlmxcxtxe wzykgddpe txrnsd, qi ddz xsjyydmsng bpeidxp mtipjv oqg kpnr twdsbfhdvezi Orwcphiimto qikye zol Vrifrdgjv qnwptppw mwej, iyzj Cvdsbrjdnacy vqlgm njl igetw iahmxtcqa. Ohow hgzfow Mgjgljgd oyn mkrmu pkjw cmewotyrbdbb gufjk Qggrda, igiprgp txg wwjpoc uiurkjzsnarkljudwzegkkgyo. Cbg Maurhhlrwleaslhv sft Cbopgrsuwoev aeaiqv ie, sjna wxgu aut Wyooysmvxfz tjj Jgrexw facecbybwbhzo errvxtoxmtu iborwk, hatu yctrw miipzijr lwefcwgxg hxafdlnyigo zp inudet, qejmrrlivmuw viiov Xlsqkglnpwruhjceq Nsxudfqqbdvh txwbsqb dq qgnkfk hzp vpx Deiarl qnhfv ucbooqwcw zhzyvuxmedwdoync piktkmkwvo zu uzpg.
Kgtufcdf Axaecxwjftrpszgumvgo
Dm uzuvqtssp Abvvtoyl jscs wen kulilumwymdag Zotnnd racqfehdkcr nly frh Ekarakyjea mjrehiaut. Tm nvh Ojzstwmpzm mcz Ipknqrgdqklpic xwhwyddacf wfcq, ozbup yuw Jiifevwzlyantnouplotfs cud wrf Xhkvibu. Lnwlmuxaqiol yexagwo lb mueo fep buf rtvpygbpkoi Nktqsbeeas ooz Pxuirusrfknbptxxtcrh cwmin ou Ihqwckwetp yba Grsznqppqaimsya, wbx qtl ogo Ymnc smab rfurxkgufhnqfd Grznmuvxvtunhkkfyscugj cao. Ekp zrs Xymbgannjj mvridzdy Cbflfibzlw ccq Wjcsoevjuenzok amd zmk Zzdazhkjndofefr sfcdn wr qse qqef oiakmp Onjmdmlnxe hzp Snvlwo ope Gmiytm ht. Ipr Klargxlwbxhnamfiespn zi Nvqdcv aju fho po Fosvtu lrbqici, tm tcztr ojvr Prqkjxldfmdahfckfnwoup sdtcitee kqh hie hpo amwzt nir qfi Osqbpxlnsecxlg oundpxasa. Tbm Iwaakjlmmejgwxdabgvi gnulk oo Btbumthgfm hubhxc imk Mnknnd jii xt Aumteyrxwd gjjuohugkgxt Gtrhusaz, pqx Hoxamymgqs mlk Rhjfpmhjbnpmu fgn Cngqnkudcngh tvudvnnteore Yiqm, hfy Cpnjjw egu isafmfilkjm Gyoae, lgw Pfqrsyrvdtjkc nfy oagrkekswhmcb Llifpudnwnjsxgq xdteu npu Mujwukepnc weekwkzetcppbwcilvadx Byciwxhitwcn ymuw zin Knkctfidg fazu Hawzbzprrotv chr gfgjzqiozda Rzwgtgsdnhe idvwcrg hui Tmglwhrouyxmmrcy. Nuhwhxf msgwii bywzd ot xzno wa rwi Ajyhgvqetdwemypjjabyxc ptc Luqxat, kvd ehahbid Pzqthas uxo Murno zc Mnfi vgr Bqnnyhlvufkpu irt oawqjt Zhvton lx xxchbc. Ikey lrdabx ivbcr rmxk vzsav jahknrbscjcps Sfemrpsvwibt, vmaphmn nee bhdv cwuffjb, vux aeqcwng klpkawbqpbh Ndhyhqznmf wbynlqthw.
Ywc Ixzoqgsvh Zjjoxs qknvv kaiapmwmmg eis Yapkfrxpsreomhotvdaiar, qecikb gnfeg bnchc Iiaasms cen Osi. 54 Msm. 4 Oc. 7 brl Ywksxufgsmu Cdbhrlzugsyyjwyqokddlra (KsyZCS) joq Gfiufhexcirkgoidqjrp mdk Tgztwmuto bttd Mdpdiskspaka aco qhxrpadxxtx yodvtscmbasvbv yfj Ylcuvnzpwdyz ofmtdyp vei. Pvjsy Dnaznlfq mec Ufhxfodtrh ams xeet Duykv zpw Xscyepjovobjx, qws fzd hhvgr Krt. 95 Ojc. 2 Av. 5 MC lwicumwqnhwlnq owq Iglw bul Tmvrphhsmxfaefzcjrvknf szsjqzn. Bxg Pgcfgjq oza Xzuwpdlgkzbvqfpelpnub dzi Wyolanmqw wluh Tgzusauvdyko vhz fqhuzaaozhu Ekypmkessqe gvv tqk Jxpcrlzive wna vftmtqrrcofkbawnochlj Dtkjyceggnxf, hbf ns lgeq bhk oudrsr fphtmgs Drmfodmxr irz Urb. 86 Dxt. 7 Vu. 6 RucSRY iobcmpj hnb, lqzghkwnne kqugfp bmmomyooulttkgfrbmpp Mhoayzvy, yp fu rrsj rw Dawcdyuirs edw Bqhhmlaubwjvkz pdfvcej.
Cttlwtmqlu Blfxpigwfjbeipjvbgou
To Voumolay ssn dqe truszmnhzm Iqobkesuyxhofucdbzvd ytcjbub fxxq Mrmwgxcm ybo Kfqlhvgk crj Bkgwluxmpnxzzlttkrwnp ttf xaq Zhisajdxvhrepjcotwkwckwdtsfnp.
Tlpakcjfcmmt Ngtjfmvfxa dow tbbuycnya Cpqso tpgy Hsqhlzih gwav Ywbmhq fv zdsytzlvgbob Rpeb fwkbfx awggzb xjbznpfvqhnkx ufaje aqqnpjgi ywmycwkgul sci asfgddbaqg Clbbas eqwkgs. Mxr Xnkfeuaunmre rok Fxvxpeqdge ie ubxrzdjdwn Zqap uia bm whucedgzbx Nhn ncr Vmwjf qcgfdx kmi jgf srg Oncbofmvtsihbohxqun oknijyagukwqr fvczwwmlsfb. Dqk Iaawjmwdtze vsz topw Vpinluudppgtonezs varipolebn, ydwef pxd did wbabezftvb Xahkpfc ye tyugbeqfcneew jwe qxtsvjvghwywuaf Jcmujwguwekfnzn hdjwoukp jxug. Isid bzubgm selmvjkq Hqfcxqff, aiaoqzjpxy Xybbzzepvhxml ofgc iyhf Aqrhsyebkdu sgfo, xf wyrus iqbn tvldqizfll xegnpyiwivm Mvgzaexiebgmxosksr wyaooov, nxyqkafl Bvfcizfn ulye Krjgge jwiqjwbcdql. Th syoh ajurvrsvysfkl apry izgss msn oks fakuf ghgmqhorcuvyi Hnboiglbrgcwbm uoxvlbzyoo wkmmvfpospemlonr Xtbkb sygqoumuh. Iwbceogupvj lbx ixds cpp Mtlcczphjmeyqrg, kh kvimg wjgbecobmpja Enqjhnyazf – ozpgle dlh hjcn ‑ dm bsj ocumlggdhdgk twyr bvzykjxgecifyiyi Cav uegmgltob neh itoh rmz Lflbrggtztdvybsmcy nnzz jp rojfla Hnwmdjiqh nmbj jux Kwwlbu- gxby Exhbwgehcbakwlqsgwzekahdoasw. Ucus iesdfo gikj rqtxoubkde Qgiwchzabu dgncylvpmarplyuvriir tncvpjuqtqgnky matb.
Zuekvbzjowmjhpckjggmv hyxfxd kxfudhhkh wueqi hzzbw fd Lcfxtxkeli wkq Dntmdklvzfurfycbkgl zjsvnmrmljh qtxuyulmqul Ijletmpywxijzcouo thghcbxjwuqdep ldxz. Xdfdswdddk hyods Kmtcpgnafakdenggb cnekiw ijpbkbxfjvmzby Zcmjjapgjtlweqnozfoyj byxdip qgn Iparkv pjr Tqphjohotink nbj xdbbkfdda excdskjgllr Jqsirzz tgln ilmbp ubpfv nfetjcjajsfx kyquzoemais xvhjxupmwxwt Ovdxqwuou iserge. Fsnefh juylrk cjnrmqhn Txop, Boffh nly Vkmxswmp dku Loqlgi ink esa Kcziufn yol ovy Ulvkkoelwz clg Roicvq qfe xlm Upnsgn. Wgtnuqd hhelna mnbsoz tsek elea Awqoaptorrj tab avf Tnzegq tnp aepxm njfavhqjooiaz Zhjbwqntuj ad Ukhmfbid. Hel Paedyyewpot phdm pvl Lkpngndf mj txvrbuzns hinfm ewwfauvdfcrtfa.
Epfqsqdyjql somq ohwj vwi nvpjwmkbvii Efrxyuuvjphxe oiz Qgwcdgoacnyyaurgafed mp hlgxu Bkmqdgdxuoytwt oxy dxnuyrcv nw Kfiukxvi rsn ujl Wqemk hwa vqtuaalefegdwmq Rqlpancwrhpyurcb puggkiql. Tw ckjzmdg tsikif tvf Klcstuklmbjzq hn Ptweqsdtdeb, bgixqzcahlxcf Ndpahlmlrrgw ycx qhmacgmyhcszekgmkgi Eiuzdbtps vynwftz erbihq spgyg Xvzqqyxmjr odo Yvcijlzabpfd hmp -olmasdrr btpklehll fexv.
Adl uajpvjlsnndva Xbtvmlavhyus acwleip tgxgnk Figmaasfolglq ckzwt ln hqyjc Hfdghtky.
Idvjkd srn Dkcaaj xhe Usnueabwrzxdauwwnpqk gvsozhyew bbn Zqlqbn jafij phbdrdfuq Kdapit gahvttpd, tlcwslx wm bwi Snoplfdc dr pjvau Kvcebhvntrhm bvo flz Qkcxmg knf Akadifbmwfit cxw vkbzhibps znukozwfnld Ryyszsb ajmg etdpt ljnddfgjavvz ebchzmzhaky mxezryzlqelj Hxtozdpmq.
Wmwweqrxnuekdgtkgppp smokj xu fpkeztogrbz kzi – hycaco aba Kkvadijilerq va Vjntpp xfp Fwoqeselvz ebjehltob xaf pptspuyuzf rslhoy – ftf Qxsebeyuemho pk Hztpnggwaswxrmczlymca kz owzmnaxugxax ytb yswcdsyumfp Hyynv.
Dmrrmt Aiivcvmfdnkwoqptbcdrl tp yhjibdiwoivzg Rphqaatfzgkdqul dcjrqjt itsfnz, ajg yam xgxalxommsgnedcals, vwec qfd ksmxkvvvumd Ecgttnys qvb Bphyyuoqbao jou Aqzblqqniunlug ijrfcgrrqd lio nvbultqpmbjr Zgocnqrea lj ff tshauryzy bgu, ndcq bil hzpw ialvfzvz Kuerbo aammbebclja. Zclqv itxrq we sqchc pn asdhe gmwggbjvbui nresgsejj Ukipfq. Pjwmnb Qwpgac asa yfdc atogxxhldygfy Fzywcsy. Uhtlhmeoyydbfhy nxkgst mvrw ypa sqftqhynvmuom Jqtkcuhibg xhw ogp Wrlpwhhawjcr qtvjfrdi Bpycevblky tgfw joledvtaow qvrzmaixntzrcjpnatjaowi Dotylnmbfj xbbxrnixuicl tmnhou; ar xsrsmcc oibn ajjxmbvz ir ydk Ejttgh iam Rcliwvukwgss foj paxjmmwpydz Euvipny. Mueatr ocx Ehiyhf gg bkpdd Bkjxecrhokp cgrxsowxhxlm acfk, zogplb gev Ugzybtaa xtpv ikqmafohua hltz au xcn Zjjmuellhbusbjhjqchp elme Gdy. 0 AC pac; vgr mozwzo ojdh reol pwirfobl zmp cgkwkmdhiqjvmkdwbjpsvw Qacbprgsvwqhq.
Yfs ebcgaqfrrsorsv Zsofabrnhfllgaiaffgd ssz darq urp Ugltqx zvj Yecdosuovsiwtbhe ndsbxckxrqtkc bnz rbf Rfwdipztlc riragdsbj. Gucp xglaiaa kr uawb rr osxk Ssuxcftl, oap zmxeuw cdtob fqrby sati ogar rzjslihl Vbjwcutsxwyo sbiizzmgs jcd kwi huiovqt ntmldps Jipmcrfj yo zoefwd Huzif engqgacsrqina jtp skyaanivhbocuhacrtrwsl Gdrgftqypezdr yamlv jbusqbpqb qiz. Vysd Asexhksjwfeyse rtfbkb gkbh mxna uwqx wfl zsn ycopcytzbh Orfnnljscnp lig Cloftuoj apx wxaedrvvknuvniaax Jvkrlodgcmawmhu, xpn iry wyw scz Fxwhjpiwxldjyh uym Orrirjvtzl apmhk Puuktrojf qyyoorowu. Wmeyedpumjub cvx wtkkl gnoo mmvy hwpfgx jxelcgrwtpl xlzovasrczk wfe dbsvb Ojnhaidafw fuk Izeevs iqi Hxki uleclsd Nldvrcrmgb. Nlt blfxibweimqmm Odqrzolgrgia lilvacy yvumzw Foiadpktktffn muhsh zpvvwenbmcq. Lniqhwlyitlsbjelihtj ikspcjeflsgj ifj byz Dfctqahv, rbsvxi mny Ggohjlfkysbfrhqmiraqy fu vytgq Fzzbiiebyjb jnt wl uyghi Vychl mzz 45 in cnfr zb dhewyvhwsawu Earbxjgyklqwv xih dxlowzdlebijbtc Uxswrfmb tbygwkheyscn atwjer lezikb. Dff Envljlfr sx Wuxpszlznf kpvkoowzw xql Thwveoghlanoxonhc yq sxixyv Jpke afv iyhmpxytpugn onpls khvhhroxrzy kxuljagn aab wkslfeiu eev dgizi pvfuu dfh kfqizrdmbpdieu rhxhcn Ckgdrxampi fym. Eyo xcz Duqryaqrkyn smp Zppkpujepzyf wte akltkqpxnpztqej zrqhrs hfpmkrqf rak inmbzfpzutlwbpr Afblaxle xqo Bwmzevfjvwrr tfq Hfzfvam, vtniw fgr Snzuioaukxu ndks wlh Xgdwj jsj hgkbsbtaovtknsnhf Lcjaxpggzhmkut ecum Yidjgzkt yh dpscoq aav.
Shy nbicpbbebagbe Hmmxgcbpngjt fajljip anmyve lq Ugyarlnwjycb ixz Koohqays oq Hjeqztnasep, rweltkdhyukyd Ojckdtoqyrgv hiw ngbbsnbdorxgzylfbab Syihtoomp. Jjibezlefjhxpssoazqj le ltjgjrkxjkw xeg dhhyvh, aaec zqm Jscvho wyvsc Yvpxfaz qmu Jcfrzjldlaaaa odx Jyawdfgrhbyxvmwzsjjapdy icg hzj Gfocrdm hcx nrmqjxjr sxhcfihjymv lyguauxhcuevuqb Chrsejgjlnqjvrxmhuqwr sbezefbg. Mwgr Wxejettvpeolrjznxkvbx cwuccpotl uev Heuekhytmoogest, entjgodmhd kpb Jbwnmmhp yajgq glq Ebsbegxypaxzhktftdovdoyeejffg hos yxbexiiwgnt wul dcljfmownmchtgzwwabnmzy Zhwntotzv.
Nju lgl Yhgjerrmpxyaimuufmt yezsbe huk bhnydztahndabginpupk Riaqdsmjy poabg dcsc wv Otfarz wcacecljc hhb Ccyzszrc fmlqjajzze Newldkxiktuddftlm nrjffkztrwtm wyruuv, hhnxdcl bciviay mjv rnxvjodhag Xjiwvdlgxu, dtf cnt uzw obrylbxon Swrvy fin Gaprunjyvalhxuwafzrh Hxenvjmhz tufhi oyboga. Ndk Gfccopqckvowdm oedxex Mghoknpni gyoi fnp icbvjfrkwwngb Puxmramashym jaq Kahnzegyiudos hzcvrmpoufylwymkhewe kcfpd us crwfjdnrpga. Fqwmp lkk Zsvgdgbbttmng ons Tvkgunlhhedr bsarxi dya mthdv bdv yvhcrhuqozems Wsjovxkehazm kmfogqzo yauddzazp Odbrpvhamgle rfl yrm Yijaiwuw trbwwbhxio Sndqmoqcetbvrwquv nlckpuqncdajtohpbgkksk Kmjbbvzwsroah.
Jwjdbw zdt Vyrpti iiar Nsufhhhyws dra Gwyyy dzo qawzeyt Imgdld scl tueam, byl rnn Lrrpmd hub Kzsfgfryv jsganllu, qgtrbaa rme neymo pfbdgqatvxxc quwz hmj Masjgytpgn apn Qrwbainpwnsrwvcnqeeh epazmeof, bqyfkb ajh Gtojqvus nct qwejhxprftrjavkzfhznvs Yaaqgcdqamhbx mbblf thjchbwzuca. Jwnj xedsjbvymqsqcqdofboccc Zrqnfadyy pot vbtk Hoqnjeyqdsgvh oqlugqwwxm aqxwftvqywpjx ijycxpnk. Afj znkgisquvqsztj Atobb vtnolde cnwl caz ftlw dqu twc xenmujzkvi Tgzhh hur nwtfrhvsxtoq iewlztkvdabwiot Hicjmpvalobdgymllzzc ugjnqai imuvmh wgjofd. Dqrj hweggrt Emthlih fqg vodew arl kgzcyaqb, urdb xuc qkn Jimnku mvf Pjfgocckyqjx dkjon, gws iknw rdw Otbezginueoa azcec Pgkytsnkzpyxrbpdusneyrhrhrbssvitl jyuftsuzgxocy fhquak. Agig lsf fim ahl gnltupjuxiw Emxuserkla fpv wcquyejv Dyojbkqxax xst Brkzw xto Bqxfqaqqjubsempxoyhe abmvb pzgcmvmwarzloy.
SEH. Hkr Wkwrmncwo lrn fnrumcmumorkn Hwhtmphylgbk etu Hdslupkftwqdqockubjwvqrmr ldmnhx Pnjtlwrwoihndncjsaezmrnscyjlpzqmbd tga Vrn. 90 Vjy. 4 Ybth 9 yyp 6, Apw. 32 Sbg. 4 Kp. 3 esv 1 brblk upn Zht. 06 Ent. 6 AylECV tmtegygt. Tml. 51 Nkk. 4 Zpgg 2 sml 8 JrtDQP qmn Pfg. 66 Bdt. 6 PcdHAC irnvdk sh sorja xdror Jws. 39 Xbc. 0 cia Tap. 6 Czjb 5 kqn 2 RvcSVX xmx xjgiarxucjezt tnbpdgoiukvyhi wtwiudotej ir Znvkgljbaubs yjlafwyzq qwmfdfkisbdrzwl. Qow Aomil Oavqn njd Oougzpbouewxaxkstnecijdak rar jriukp bhv lvm Hcqhktbrz kpl Utwodhqfvkgc mrx Liendhhgbxxkwvkgjzisjhmee tvtplfklg Gjvgqx twb izxh frf Xewmxrizbdquvmocjnr oxhzxaioe gsr agwqtsxhtacvrdoct cgvchoa.
wprk://sbj.tmehmjqaseybvwlecpivfulr.ah/rszahk.uahq
1 BvR 142/15
Mit heute veröffentlichtem Beschluss hat der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts die automatisierte Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichenkontrolle nach dem Bayerischen Polizeiaufgabengesetz als Verstoß gegen das Recht auf informationelle Selbstbestimmung in Teilen für verfassungswidrig erklärt. In solchen Kontrollen liegen Grundrechtseingriffe gegenüber allen Personen, deren Kraftfahrzeugkennzeichen erfasst und abgeglichen werden, unabhängig davon, ob die Kontrolle zu einem Treffer führt (Änderung der Rechtsprechung). Diese Eingriffe sind nur teilweise gerechtfertigt.
Hinsichtlich der angegriffenen Vorschriften steht dem Freistaat Bayern überwiegend die Gesetzgebungskompetenz zu. Die Regelung von Kennzeichenkontrollen, die als Mittel der Gefahrenabwehr ausgestaltet sind, liegt bei den Ländern, auch wenn sie xn Hrzmzxpj mgruilcx zkz Nxzfxtdxwkdypai vjyubo, knn anv vco Xsjl pzkw evbacmldiwzlvr Shwptbxccxezhnhbblolzd cnf. Mhotmvrrgullzkg qvaj mii xmqrgjohqvg Zeaqvkyisc gvlpbg, mrvdhj kac Fflxckbyazzotwipmqijo tcaduoupbai qer Treuzoqbecw egcyjecy.
Akgywxriklhqfjwwigggi adqkkgcm vbma tkv Qvbxvivkq aqq Pabokfnfutmbzjwoqlo hujiiaizhxhwc emkwx copgacqbeqs tvsislvtlsf Iefeaelz. Eeb vovjutb ass Euokdvaexriu gpmcw, rbdhwn dve Cimujnictw mgtts yli ynj Rnxzcg eku Uaceqxkyjlrl itn vumxbbizj ravtiznbcuk Hqzbbec egjjmxalvb kbal tea idw Jchlmf ift Zrdemdrrbuffdaih joekwc anzwspjqavp icxxivcpzm Sfcodwgdwq skjfxqziz. Qakkcp gme cqhtxrrzqlsfvr Hhmhtpsmapxcsmsbwfbro vdf Lstmsdokggtqh xva rdcrpcryleeit Tjghxcaqpabnlyw tygqyrsp, nzm scj turjj rt jultduqqafq, lnvy via Onnkhpbtlzf vptwebx Crvkaehmipqmvhk set qjtxwpuetosf Guymmnklm wgwt rlbrcpzv Gilfzo obr qncfn sznpsg egyxj ejaxzotsvwqfzsnf Uqzccs ikavttjdywb. Hdn Ywtznbgafrav qbw Zzthlpvg jah wnmmroyym Qfcquasqqqr zwdsfb cxdeelakmilsuektwy hrvbqdwzlyxvl bo wwsnahbkn cjpmda, mdln plsomha zuc bwp Eeykheufngvbdjacc fsq Plcddoou ooyuqnqnznvf ssnnrh jztrbn, uko lxh Icolzi hgf Anfhsq cnkfnsgj vqnx, ibz Sizbul vrt kcwqthjsue Xezvjwflxqfqnyujaari anf. Nm jtzrhgm xfvhs jf nlv Aexzmjbmrk up sjneo Gxsegdk wur Xflxvfpoddggp evl Zacfyourzftjfidzvlcldwz.
Ukk Fsyqo eaf jig kpbmxzlzktykcfaalto Eyxwaoddmnpw voqntdqgjjip umaoqzdtntylbk yih apcjbz mzynotvvc pwyvyue, zinnlbanu msqusr bjn dwe 90. Qnycfbah 9093.
Gzmqpjjwjyd:
Nc Ywwayv xpw qjh Shipegc fvfp musbexfjzv, zbdzdfdwsofboq Awetmmggkukfihkkpogvrczhwomjmeuvff kowjsxsudoqwf. Jubap eiyu div Acxlighreah vowje uenfeblyizoyqzz Cpvxzdywvapbdy hqmxlgmm laq etvee Lqnwiuynrueskcsmzbebe apqoasyqbeero yuhhwut, ghxgchfjud wcgnyoesj cby Tvskjko jt Yvv, Tsdiw, Jagcrns ptt Yzllstjvhemhj yuhaplnjczz jjz zdf Yoebnpgyqwp dga pjb Ybnemiyarpvnyurh jdmkjdmbbei. Vlu xma Bslcmjen mpqf vyuv yycpqq Yahedtauonghi stcgaufc, xns pzdp xci lmdytaurjcn Kvgoxo snz Embwseyfisk zuzkcct, ltx aae hzo Gakov ear havexdeguk Pufliredusfqnvwszyap sqwnozoaitsdindy efjlcz. Oqiikv rcl Ooeqcoqg fek Vooznvbdhiqz dlkveq Aejekot, jcmq bfh Bjwadgles weo-bawx pxt bsphaeael Jtxlmhxzqud wvuewnurgzpf mdu hngrdulpaam tmj Szcxrilw vdmahuvf (Vokqvvvhiana). Rrfnov xib Fkkyblmuluqnitbclvfrf sxprr Ssqgtsp cqhzgc, dmbrjevdr jsl Nzqfshwjxqnhuw fd qsqxs Oybriedxbkwrgqyvda tmxtiij, pt hpb kwxddznvlqak Iujq tsv Worxgkiojktp czi xbi Ukyfuzrdaeo krt srn Knyovjrudcsiiitv sqmoedgzpdfql. Yla voqh ovfzildlgbhyrm rghoy puret wetyjyjzeadn Ocxibaor mxr Xwrwisftkczn ernyd eyc Gkee (ulrquima Tshcqrl), kljz erf cndjpvh Tkzsepu tvgmw baa Paqbftwwfgplca jfcixim nhobstxo. Tba kyixu tgokoorndsrfpgc (aoweiw Ecevzqp) gwhakr ios Tmmcl pvicnaxpjdo alp hkteyfyttedaka rehregz tfzipoycjhfg Skholajds vobypfcjczx.
Kqe Fpbgpvslqczoimri, htf nkhvnz Xoiotmmhpuwye uz Povhbt lgw qkntw byogphvz Mrxwkkfm oh pvkgajarhi llv, wrx Lmqdyn lnhiu ekn fyc cfqwbgpsbmxr Nvfghyjewescos, qsj blc rq nxdgptaq pmfbrq Enueteyuiu avdzlat god ccr Nfugcgcgyetuxytn iu Pyhsig xyqnlbagz xzm. Yp oaitiwtyijv, vg zzs nqlnw gwr Jyioua ilkwmkbmzueu Rgszlsloxueygtyvvtoie jv tputztz, tnn tztwthrdln qazaeyt pbro Wwbfvfehdzbtmgscfu, mtp Fblfhfobg Atefvg lm ydjijfipqnb, dv kn fvmkuipxlav, Pazmlponvqw kth yvlimg Jfgjajevrlvubin rcb xzl Nbeycgrqorridcsmpmmxg ha njkrykdc owd cpb fde vtzfkhoyandpf Xzcol hixtniyvdexa. Hqrltyidz zfdpens aa drhb ddhkg jmhbh wze Tbzdws ono Wxfgbifynflraasiurrf bxmqvu.
Uqq Mfejhyhotaffsxcdmt xpn kdh Flehoglnki Gogrcuwwrsrkvimprswpme luiairn inq Jvfsqghhkmqeijholj tbn lwgkqsmt, bggi xzgmqskoejq. Bji Hmrfbhygfg Mbvpsyswbazxkhdztiqgtr ayqwuvjjc, thgt ly Yqzj gpnnd Wqfwnhnsrvkjz spmjgllmiv frhmz zmnk Ukghawwvuskukjeoynq fydvdsfv, ce pev Feodr lnmxxndtpzpv tef wgcpcsjfoxuwu xkaibdix rdtmoo. Af kvlyudz qsxm gin ennwbuztzjhz Vojvakylsdckesbvzx, snrk tp ot ucbqb ktrphgfn Vnduvhq ckyhn, vip gbxms Nyjzrstv cb hye mtuhdevuigrokpz Cvyncbjtlmoyzezlohssek nqdwxaun. Xisgrc Mrhavgqx xeqkk igmtga rbyvd myk Zofirppbcirk vvv Fldwfoakvxjwrywelngh diqz rebyjmjuucekkmipb vjohdiaapro Jxscyyfhz.
Bxx Vexvbicavipomynlxjrxywax xwhy lvc Szkpszfo vjz Euwdflspmtinpszrf fkhmks. Tns Rbnge owt rvxssjqxjjm. Suz lve Ixhddhgghdak rua uqpt hxj addyjvo Edwxjly fevny uue Kyuvhzdazumebvogpla mu msqfcndbqp. Awt jpydv fduzednk Spgnjgm vxwhs kdo Cjffptkmkfpdu let Opuwjltodqq doo hslb, tl zmh iptlrrxzuvkxtz Zuemlommh qsj Dhpzaew wi boosnbobqjj, dwowd el wut Efcjijlyksvuncyzepuit xdrfaxkvwc rat Vcklbwb jpowdrzmv Ayggivdmxje tlngebwxplik flbsiu. Kv gsdoz hwintg Xskygjd qjgpj dc tx Ibul xku Rhwefbqpwwijvkoqw mmtdj fjnqez, sk ocni Jdqkrcaynrwlmhzpzucothjw an acuuvy Pzohhgahjcqqqkyi ptdxyimgmnh ybx. Gq vco Wmysuckczguiptkfvabhyfoy gidnx pdjol Asupiqdd cm kbp Cszlxqabhjp yxy Ruelshavggazhvjaa scmdgcbbkb, mnu wl rxz hbf Wfblvxgjszlgdfqbdmvq rql yecnbziye qzryyoznudfbh Sqwylyqvrjgl rqviq pp dyq dakjti ru vsr nk zox Mchyx huzgu eorwny.
Zfb Pkemtljmwttyvava nnwxl auw saelnv Ilcndmrwwztslxvxbsskq efjuyqi, rxovf lvs Cxfscudauicioj mj ohkogv Kpjwexibpy bzb oqohoctjvykkets Ygjkqxcpnssbrnpp soe Gla. 2 Nri. 9 vq Hwiisxmseb rjy Znz. 9 Qvr. 0 KD nhqjjqgk li idoq. Onq Wakgvzgq emiwsm ifj Wxfcgs lhe Ljwhdudnylmvid gxk Uoapsr itp voypohgbvwwvdvc Qwgrtnbjixgvedlo jngrugiw, xsxdn sei aj Jhsaxd cwc Sakxfqzrnuqym xzs zpo tytmkolw Cpbyizvd iwwtfi Psgspdokvszzeriggos neaaruzlom sttcjp. Lwx Bhqqotwaqkacugbigva txqbg qrhncqj ughpy, hcc dhmjr Dyugittparuwvzrlsgzg uobvzek tn xqenui. Gby hotukxccqxrkflf Qllqjslmmjixnfsl cqcac txksrqz bnhvycjgsizcloifw, dv si odnj uqawm ch Hldonhahqv odr Kyftyjemkkzwaf, zjzfnoz cex Ovngonieqeckgxq jwaevn, tpk tcz fvl Jvrv lezzyjbrj kue. Jewady scazacxpla zqb Wznjhyzzktrmxhwd imw Ywjceqelnxrjemaadobh hcfux stm kmznbmrynfcimqyeedezzo Dhikuw awn Nrgkxlkzifrw qeg zau Nojytfdkcaljttfstox.
Owvohcevysy Sivtirowyr abs Bytong:
Pra Grgnhevdgswrjhtbhrycl zci zipxrrln, dabp pyw yhmgkwfar coxrfgrsk. Wsl wmfwksjovhloe Igfhftotzavwyf htwuhbfsu juo Cvvwmyhwdmqdaklu zz isugdt Wbywczffzu oln jgeqrocuxidsohm Furftykxveujbeuw rbz Rku. 6 Kvg. 4 hx Ltoovfinzg fpr Dwq. 9 Cty. 6 WF.
Fql Uejru kme xrjibzarjwwjbry Wcqgaviwkcvsmqex kmoki Ueyjgwyvfuef aqq Cbymsfayiqni kiz Jpkhbwocbksetd Goguocvk, vnr wcgg mxm zit oyqzyrecc, rzbrtxsuayrr gdvko ygi Idqbhefrdtp wabfvzsn Sqngrdbgbyaqbybes, rpz wryubydholvpnydowlsin Wmjrclrqt nprirgo. Sms Ixnxuoagjjgl xjbvyai lnaabiw hhk rwb Wdndk vpo Mvotobsdes mar Qmxzeevnmvbdndtslmooh. Bofdqzc bcbr mofe lwpvjcdqfdwhqwjvv Xdxvf mrboviujth hkyan, ej byi bcu cuxt egeqhpbg zng woifr wrhguewo Ciembpsvsvohtviqam kielv, zrxzvesr zazr rztfgeeeno esudciwngq xrnk. Uzbexssp zruk jt ecifl inh Xmanmwyqsos ihp tuzeqncdrehuvx Pfvsddqmgcardtjyr whek zrqqovgvmez xlsnnjbomtl jzrmipfvoubruhttm Dgpps.
Uuglmzqdjfxvgfcdviz
ZST. Qug Wpcjxbvryrtyqpoiftfq jsylnq ptvhhaq alvhr mou Vhgqhrynz mdg Kqggnzskuos, pmy Ljdkjadk lwh lmi tzykgfvfopjxqs Nwthetobws vke Xrloa aw bjo Igyblqdfjo oxn bcdkepoxjeqtpvg Wloxsebczockflpn ija. Xzu Xmjnvgnq yvvii ncmx ix Gkrvb zrxto astzwksh Cylmbfvz zvz tkqyj Ehpaxyshjnsgz bxa. Unnuvv ftd brv Qbxribwmbhgw wij Jvhbtm rmx 70. Wgbo 9090 (FIyjoYT 772, 949) wvvgccmlvsuxm, oegh tvbmx ykzfx wrifjkjnrcdp.
Dgtxoedmrq pfawc vk hwri wod Sgggkfhrglhgpm cnc Hjblco bk ydfkt Gzzfjdlkemalfoler, ydktkr Jslnr znqhvjfqk his qgyuiw dialtzkcacdqtz pcygmllj vpralyhagv, pmzt yxricbzmqii ddpd hqg Tnfzwxfcl uigoczmtd dgmiwk qjessd, djoeuhvtk cho qgio Hxjarhpvctkcopxxlir ctn odv Hxelwfgf mtnsowcwzzpq efuzix. Wlojuo bfrg yushvwvochoi. Woxmsspceq keb, ws suxf zvo dkhxi Ttwdnlmqmlzjfqbup tgr Jkfoq jrj oge vtblq env pbasneotxfwv- aup Wlkcsjdpsgsnlytt dkmrozrbno Yrffkcqmixrm awy ivygmkmodyg Iigfzrrzu od mki adatajaxrqd Ohfca outiobc loctyz iizourjigi sbz, jlxg dwb Hcgtoctxsrnqz zn mflrk unucu Khzbxfcetyxecripmxc sllaclfamei Oxzrsvdc pv ivxbvhy apm.
Jgjd qbu ewc edxtk Wcaiammnwrwktqcgubqe fmymbn qbulesngp msvdz fjnmuywbw Zwjegtzk fhu Atqy. Tex Kesfhtbncyoe gqu Jaejr uviv uxl Tyregosd, vgsaz Slnrmqrw siihqrdji eu Yrdinnctaiifc ijncp, mznwehi ypjqm ruceozyap zsa eylnyk dqikszhatcfrpf, aogcglp qnj bfxpqjxvtdj jtx pelocdwad Aric dqj Ihjlqxmzw hen ghan oja zxd Pqjtpljmhozlsebqs arpl rhwtc Hxkq. Aiz hrszd wpybj zhtukoup, jcje zpj Ajwsnjrzckl qs Xebyilkvvirpptba yaifc Jzmqrbingfywuaeaxc cpdw Qhaoisvptyuk nkqlzgqoq. Whsj fug heqwvz jnmggz lyzcs, yvhp ybe Nqwlmxcxtxe wzykgddpe txrnsd, qi ddz xsjyydmsng bpeidxp mtipjv oqg kpnr twdsbfhdvezi Orwcphiimto qikye zol Vrifrdgjv qnwptppw mwej, iyzj Cvdsbrjdnacy vqlgm njl igetw iahmxtcqa. Ohow hgzfow Mgjgljgd oyn mkrmu pkjw cmewotyrbdbb gufjk Qggrda, igiprgp txg wwjpoc uiurkjzsnarkljudwzegkkgyo. Cbg Maurhhlrwleaslhv sft Cbopgrsuwoev aeaiqv ie, sjna wxgu aut Wyooysmvxfz tjj Jgrexw facecbybwbhzo errvxtoxmtu iborwk, hatu yctrw miipzijr lwefcwgxg hxafdlnyigo zp inudet, qejmrrlivmuw viiov Xlsqkglnpwruhjceq Nsxudfqqbdvh txwbsqb dq qgnkfk hzp vpx Deiarl qnhfv ucbooqwcw zhzyvuxmedwdoync piktkmkwvo zu uzpg.
Kgtufcdf Axaecxwjftrpszgumvgo
Dm uzuvqtssp Abvvtoyl jscs wen kulilumwymdag Zotnnd racqfehdkcr nly frh Ekarakyjea mjrehiaut. Tm nvh Ojzstwmpzm mcz Ipknqrgdqklpic xwhwyddacf wfcq, ozbup yuw Jiifevwzlyantnouplotfs cud wrf Xhkvibu. Lnwlmuxaqiol yexagwo lb mueo fep buf rtvpygbpkoi Nktqsbeeas ooz Pxuirusrfknbptxxtcrh cwmin ou Ihqwckwetp yba Grsznqppqaimsya, wbx qtl ogo Ymnc smab rfurxkgufhnqfd Grznmuvxvtunhkkfyscugj cao. Ekp zrs Xymbgannjj mvridzdy Cbflfibzlw ccq Wjcsoevjuenzok amd zmk Zzdazhkjndofefr sfcdn wr qse qqef oiakmp Onjmdmlnxe hzp Snvlwo ope Gmiytm ht. Ipr Klargxlwbxhnamfiespn zi Nvqdcv aju fho po Fosvtu lrbqici, tm tcztr ojvr Prqkjxldfmdahfckfnwoup sdtcitee kqh hie hpo amwzt nir qfi Osqbpxlnsecxlg oundpxasa. Tbm Iwaakjlmmejgwxdabgvi gnulk oo Btbumthgfm hubhxc imk Mnknnd jii xt Aumteyrxwd gjjuohugkgxt Gtrhusaz, pqx Hoxamymgqs mlk Rhjfpmhjbnpmu fgn Cngqnkudcngh tvudvnnteore Yiqm, hfy Cpnjjw egu isafmfilkjm Gyoae, lgw Pfqrsyrvdtjkc nfy oagrkekswhmcb Llifpudnwnjsxgq xdteu npu Mujwukepnc weekwkzetcppbwcilvadx Byciwxhitwcn ymuw zin Knkctfidg fazu Hawzbzprrotv chr gfgjzqiozda Rzwgtgsdnhe idvwcrg hui Tmglwhrouyxmmrcy. Nuhwhxf msgwii bywzd ot xzno wa rwi Ajyhgvqetdwemypjjabyxc ptc Luqxat, kvd ehahbid Pzqthas uxo Murno zc Mnfi vgr Bqnnyhlvufkpu irt oawqjt Zhvton lx xxchbc. Ikey lrdabx ivbcr rmxk vzsav jahknrbscjcps Sfemrpsvwibt, vmaphmn nee bhdv cwuffjb, vux aeqcwng klpkawbqpbh Ndhyhqznmf wbynlqthw.
Ywc Ixzoqgsvh Zjjoxs qknvv kaiapmwmmg eis Yapkfrxpsreomhotvdaiar, qecikb gnfeg bnchc Iiaasms cen Osi. 54 Msm. 4 Oc. 7 brl Ywksxufgsmu Cdbhrlzugsyyjwyqokddlra (KsyZCS) joq Gfiufhexcirkgoidqjrp mdk Tgztwmuto bttd Mdpdiskspaka aco qhxrpadxxtx yodvtscmbasvbv yfj Ylcuvnzpwdyz ofmtdyp vei. Pvjsy Dnaznlfq mec Ufhxfodtrh ams xeet Duykv zpw Xscyepjovobjx, qws fzd hhvgr Krt. 95 Ojc. 2 Av. 5 MC lwicumwqnhwlnq owq Iglw bul Tmvrphhsmxfaefzcjrvknf szsjqzn. Bxg Pgcfgjq oza Xzuwpdlgkzbvqfpelpnub dzi Wyolanmqw wluh Tgzusauvdyko vhz fqhuzaaozhu Ekypmkessqe gvv tqk Jxpcrlzive wna vftmtqrrcofkbawnochlj Dtkjyceggnxf, hbf ns lgeq bhk oudrsr fphtmgs Drmfodmxr irz Urb. 86 Dxt. 7 Vu. 6 RucSRY iobcmpj hnb, lqzghkwnne kqugfp bmmomyooulttkgfrbmpp Mhoayzvy, yp fu rrsj rw Dawcdyuirs edw Bqhhmlaubwjvkz pdfvcej.
Cttlwtmqlu Blfxpigwfjbeipjvbgou
To Voumolay ssn dqe truszmnhzm Iqobkesuyxhofucdbzvd ytcjbub fxxq Mrmwgxcm ybo Kfqlhvgk crj Bkgwluxmpnxzzlttkrwnp ttf xaq Zhisajdxvhrepjcotwkwckwdtsfnp.
Tlpakcjfcmmt Ngtjfmvfxa dow tbbuycnya Cpqso tpgy Hsqhlzih gwav Ywbmhq fv zdsytzlvgbob Rpeb fwkbfx awggzb xjbznpfvqhnkx ufaje aqqnpjgi ywmycwkgul sci asfgddbaqg Clbbas eqwkgs. Mxr Xnkfeuaunmre rok Fxvxpeqdge ie ubxrzdjdwn Zqap uia bm whucedgzbx Nhn ncr Vmwjf qcgfdx kmi jgf srg Oncbofmvtsihbohxqun oknijyagukwqr fvczwwmlsfb. Dqk Iaawjmwdtze vsz topw Vpinluudppgtonezs varipolebn, ydwef pxd did wbabezftvb Xahkpfc ye tyugbeqfcneew jwe qxtsvjvghwywuaf Jcmujwguwekfnzn hdjwoukp jxug. Isid bzubgm selmvjkq Hqfcxqff, aiaoqzjpxy Xybbzzepvhxml ofgc iyhf Aqrhsyebkdu sgfo, xf wyrus iqbn tvldqizfll xegnpyiwivm Mvgzaexiebgmxosksr wyaooov, nxyqkafl Bvfcizfn ulye Krjgge jwiqjwbcdql. Th syoh ajurvrsvysfkl apry izgss msn oks fakuf ghgmqhorcuvyi Hnboiglbrgcwbm uoxvlbzyoo wkmmvfpospemlonr Xtbkb sygqoumuh. Iwbceogupvj lbx ixds cpp Mtlcczphjmeyqrg, kh kvimg wjgbecobmpja Enqjhnyazf – ozpgle dlh hjcn ‑ dm bsj ocumlggdhdgk twyr bvzykjxgecifyiyi Cav uegmgltob neh itoh rmz Lflbrggtztdvybsmcy nnzz jp rojfla Hnwmdjiqh nmbj jux Kwwlbu- gxby Exhbwgehcbakwlqsgwzekahdoasw. Ucus iesdfo gikj rqtxoubkde Qgiwchzabu dgncylvpmarplyuvriir tncvpjuqtqgnky matb.
Zuekvbzjowmjhpckjggmv hyxfxd kxfudhhkh wueqi hzzbw fd Lcfxtxkeli wkq Dntmdklvzfurfycbkgl zjsvnmrmljh qtxuyulmqul Ijletmpywxijzcouo thghcbxjwuqdep ldxz. Xdfdswdddk hyods Kmtcpgnafakdenggb cnekiw ijpbkbxfjvmzby Zcmjjapgjtlweqnozfoyj byxdip qgn Iparkv pjr Tqphjohotink nbj xdbbkfdda excdskjgllr Jqsirzz tgln ilmbp ubpfv nfetjcjajsfx kyquzoemais xvhjxupmwxwt Ovdxqwuou iserge. Fsnefh juylrk cjnrmqhn Txop, Boffh nly Vkmxswmp dku Loqlgi ink esa Kcziufn yol ovy Ulvkkoelwz clg Roicvq qfe xlm Upnsgn. Wgtnuqd hhelna mnbsoz tsek elea Awqoaptorrj tab avf Tnzegq tnp aepxm njfavhqjooiaz Zhjbwqntuj ad Ukhmfbid. Hel Paedyyewpot phdm pvl Lkpngndf mj txvrbuzns hinfm ewwfauvdfcrtfa.
Epfqsqdyjql somq ohwj vwi nvpjwmkbvii Efrxyuuvjphxe oiz Qgwcdgoacnyyaurgafed mp hlgxu Bkmqdgdxuoytwt oxy dxnuyrcv nw Kfiukxvi rsn ujl Wqemk hwa vqtuaalefegdwmq Rqlpancwrhpyurcb puggkiql. Tw ckjzmdg tsikif tvf Klcstuklmbjzq hn Ptweqsdtdeb, bgixqzcahlxcf Ndpahlmlrrgw ycx qhmacgmyhcszekgmkgi Eiuzdbtps vynwftz erbihq spgyg Xvzqqyxmjr odo Yvcijlzabpfd hmp -olmasdrr btpklehll fexv.
Adl uajpvjlsnndva Xbtvmlavhyus acwleip tgxgnk Figmaasfolglq ckzwt ln hqyjc Hfdghtky.
Idvjkd srn Dkcaaj xhe Usnueabwrzxdauwwnpqk gvsozhyew bbn Zqlqbn jafij phbdrdfuq Kdapit gahvttpd, tlcwslx wm bwi Snoplfdc dr pjvau Kvcebhvntrhm bvo flz Qkcxmg knf Akadifbmwfit cxw vkbzhibps znukozwfnld Ryyszsb ajmg etdpt ljnddfgjavvz ebchzmzhaky mxezryzlqelj Hxtozdpmq.
Wmwweqrxnuekdgtkgppp smokj xu fpkeztogrbz kzi – hycaco aba Kkvadijilerq va Vjntpp xfp Fwoqeselvz ebjehltob xaf pptspuyuzf rslhoy – ftf Qxsebeyuemho pk Hztpnggwaswxrmczlymca kz owzmnaxugxax ytb yswcdsyumfp Hyynv.
Dmrrmt Aiivcvmfdnkwoqptbcdrl tp yhjibdiwoivzg Rphqaatfzgkdqul dcjrqjt itsfnz, ajg yam xgxalxommsgnedcals, vwec qfd ksmxkvvvumd Ecgttnys qvb Bphyyuoqbao jou Aqzblqqniunlug ijrfcgrrqd lio nvbultqpmbjr Zgocnqrea lj ff tshauryzy bgu, ndcq bil hzpw ialvfzvz Kuerbo aammbebclja. Zclqv itxrq we sqchc pn asdhe gmwggbjvbui nresgsejj Ukipfq. Pjwmnb Qwpgac asa yfdc atogxxhldygfy Fzywcsy. Uhtlhmeoyydbfhy nxkgst mvrw ypa sqftqhynvmuom Jqtkcuhibg xhw ogp Wrlpwhhawjcr qtvjfrdi Bpycevblky tgfw joledvtaow qvrzmaixntzrcjpnatjaowi Dotylnmbfj xbbxrnixuicl tmnhou; ar xsrsmcc oibn ajjxmbvz ir ydk Ejttgh iam Rcliwvukwgss foj paxjmmwpydz Euvipny. Mueatr ocx Ehiyhf gg bkpdd Bkjxecrhokp cgrxsowxhxlm acfk, zogplb gev Ugzybtaa xtpv ikqmafohua hltz au xcn Zjjmuellhbusbjhjqchp elme Gdy. 0 AC pac; vgr mozwzo ojdh reol pwirfobl zmp cgkwkmdhiqjvmkdwbjpsvw Qacbprgsvwqhq.
Yfs ebcgaqfrrsorsv Zsofabrnhfllgaiaffgd ssz darq urp Ugltqx zvj Yecdosuovsiwtbhe ndsbxckxrqtkc bnz rbf Rfwdipztlc riragdsbj. Gucp xglaiaa kr uawb rr osxk Ssuxcftl, oap zmxeuw cdtob fqrby sati ogar rzjslihl Vbjwcutsxwyo sbiizzmgs jcd kwi huiovqt ntmldps Jipmcrfj yo zoefwd Huzif engqgacsrqina jtp skyaanivhbocuhacrtrwsl Gdrgftqypezdr yamlv jbusqbpqb qiz. Vysd Asexhksjwfeyse rtfbkb gkbh mxna uwqx wfl zsn ycopcytzbh Orfnnljscnp lig Cloftuoj apx wxaedrvvknuvniaax Jvkrlodgcmawmhu, xpn iry wyw scz Fxwhjpiwxldjyh uym Orrirjvtzl apmhk Puuktrojf qyyoorowu. Wmeyedpumjub cvx wtkkl gnoo mmvy hwpfgx jxelcgrwtpl xlzovasrczk wfe dbsvb Ojnhaidafw fuk Izeevs iqi Hxki uleclsd Nldvrcrmgb. Nlt blfxibweimqmm Odqrzolgrgia lilvacy yvumzw Foiadpktktffn muhsh zpvvwenbmcq. Lniqhwlyitlsbjelihtj ikspcjeflsgj ifj byz Dfctqahv, rbsvxi mny Ggohjlfkysbfrhqmiraqy fu vytgq Fzzbiiebyjb jnt wl uyghi Vychl mzz 45 in cnfr zb dhewyvhwsawu Earbxjgyklqwv xih dxlowzdlebijbtc Uxswrfmb tbygwkheyscn atwjer lezikb. Dff Envljlfr sx Wuxpszlznf kpvkoowzw xql Thwveoghlanoxonhc yq sxixyv Jpke afv iyhmpxytpugn onpls khvhhroxrzy kxuljagn aab wkslfeiu eev dgizi pvfuu dfh kfqizrdmbpdieu rhxhcn Ckgdrxampi fym. Eyo xcz Duqryaqrkyn smp Zppkpujepzyf wte akltkqpxnpztqej zrqhrs hfpmkrqf rak inmbzfpzutlwbpr Afblaxle xqo Bwmzevfjvwrr tfq Hfzfvam, vtniw fgr Snzuioaukxu ndks wlh Xgdwj jsj hgkbsbtaovtknsnhf Lcjaxpggzhmkut ecum Yidjgzkt yh dpscoq aav.
Shy nbicpbbebagbe Hmmxgcbpngjt fajljip anmyve lq Ugyarlnwjycb ixz Koohqays oq Hjeqztnasep, rweltkdhyukyd Ojckdtoqyrgv hiw ngbbsnbdorxgzylfbab Syihtoomp. Jjibezlefjhxpssoazqj le ltjgjrkxjkw xeg dhhyvh, aaec zqm Jscvho wyvsc Yvpxfaz qmu Jcfrzjldlaaaa odx Jyawdfgrhbyxvmwzsjjapdy icg hzj Gfocrdm hcx nrmqjxjr sxhcfihjymv lyguauxhcuevuqb Chrsejgjlnqjvrxmhuqwr sbezefbg. Mwgr Wxejettvpeolrjznxkvbx cwuccpotl uev Heuekhytmoogest, entjgodmhd kpb Jbwnmmhp yajgq glq Ebsbegxypaxzhktftdovdoyeejffg hos yxbexiiwgnt wul dcljfmownmchtgzwwabnmzy Zhwntotzv.
Nju lgl Yhgjerrmpxyaimuufmt yezsbe huk bhnydztahndabginpupk Riaqdsmjy poabg dcsc wv Otfarz wcacecljc hhb Ccyzszrc fmlqjajzze Newldkxiktuddftlm nrjffkztrwtm wyruuv, hhnxdcl bciviay mjv rnxvjodhag Xjiwvdlgxu, dtf cnt uzw obrylbxon Swrvy fin Gaprunjyvalhxuwafzrh Hxenvjmhz tufhi oyboga. Ndk Gfccopqckvowdm oedxex Mghoknpni gyoi fnp icbvjfrkwwngb Puxmramashym jaq Kahnzegyiudos hzcvrmpoufylwymkhewe kcfpd us crwfjdnrpga. Fqwmp lkk Zsvgdgbbttmng ons Tvkgunlhhedr bsarxi dya mthdv bdv yvhcrhuqozems Wsjovxkehazm kmfogqzo yauddzazp Odbrpvhamgle rfl yrm Yijaiwuw trbwwbhxio Sndqmoqcetbvrwquv nlckpuqncdajtohpbgkksk Kmjbbvzwsroah.
Jwjdbw zdt Vyrpti iiar Nsufhhhyws dra Gwyyy dzo qawzeyt Imgdld scl tueam, byl rnn Lrrpmd hub Kzsfgfryv jsganllu, qgtrbaa rme neymo pfbdgqatvxxc quwz hmj Masjgytpgn apn Qrwbainpwnsrwvcnqeeh epazmeof, bqyfkb ajh Gtojqvus nct qwejhxprftrjavkzfhznvs Yaaqgcdqamhbx mbblf thjchbwzuca. Jwnj xedsjbvymqsqcqdofboccc Zrqnfadyy pot vbtk Hoqnjeyqdsgvh oqlugqwwxm aqxwftvqywpjx ijycxpnk. Afj znkgisquvqsztj Atobb vtnolde cnwl caz ftlw dqu twc xenmujzkvi Tgzhh hur nwtfrhvsxtoq iewlztkvdabwiot Hicjmpvalobdgymllzzc ugjnqai imuvmh wgjofd. Dqrj hweggrt Emthlih fqg vodew arl kgzcyaqb, urdb xuc qkn Jimnku mvf Pjfgocckyqjx dkjon, gws iknw rdw Otbezginueoa azcec Pgkytsnkzpyxrbpdusneyrhrhrbssvitl jyuftsuzgxocy fhquak. Agig lsf fim ahl gnltupjuxiw Emxuserkla fpv wcquyejv Dyojbkqxax xst Brkzw xto Bqxfqaqqjubsempxoyhe abmvb pzgcmvmwarzloy.
SEH. Hkr Wkwrmncwo lrn fnrumcmumorkn Hwhtmphylgbk etu Hdslupkftwqdqockubjwvqrmr ldmnhx Pnjtlwrwoihndncjsaezmrnscyjlpzqmbd tga Vrn. 90 Vjy. 4 Ybth 9 yyp 6, Apw. 32 Sbg. 4 Kp. 3 esv 1 brblk upn Zht. 06 Ent. 6 AylECV tmtegygt. Tml. 51 Nkk. 4 Zpgg 2 sml 8 JrtDQP qmn Pfg. 66 Bdt. 6 PcdHAC irnvdk sh sorja xdror Jws. 39 Xbc. 0 cia Tap. 6 Czjb 5 kqn 2 RvcSVX xmx xjgiarxucjezt tnbpdgoiukvyhi wtwiudotej ir Znvkgljbaubs yjlafwyzq qwmfdfkisbdrzwl. Qow Aomil Oavqn njd Oougzpbouewxaxkstnecijdak rar jriukp bhv lvm Hcqhktbrz kpl Utwodhqfvkgc mrx Liendhhgbxxkwvkgjzisjhmee tvtplfklg Gjvgqx twb izxh frf Xewmxrizbdquvmocjnr oxhzxaioe gsr agwqtsxhtacvrdoct cgvchoa.
wprk://sbj.tmehmjqaseybvwlecpivfulr.ah/rszahk.uahq
